Educational Systems and Gender Segregation in Education: A Three-Country Comparison of Germany, Norway and Canada

Abstract

How do institutional settings and their embedded policy principles affect gender-typed enrolment in educational programmes? Based on gender-sensitive theories on career choice, we hypothesised that gender segregation in education is higher with a wider range of offers of vocational programmes. By analysing youth survey and panel data, we tested this assumption for Germany, Norway and Canada, three countries whose educational systems represent a different mix of academic, vocational and universalistic education principles. We found that vocational programmes are considerably more gendersegregated than are academic (e.g., university) programmes. Men, more so than women, can avoid gender-typed programmes by passing on to a university education. This in turn means that as long as their secondary school achievement does not allow for a higher education career, they have a higher likelihood of being allocated to male-typed programmes in the vocational education and training (VET) system. In addition, social background and the age at which students have to choose educational offers mediate the transition to gendered educational programmes. Overall, gender segregation in education is highest in Germany and the lowest in Canada. We interpret the differences between these countries with respect to the constellations of educational principles and policies in the respective countries.

Labour market integration of young refugees and asylum seekers: a look at perceived barriers and resources

“…However, gender roles seemed to influence the participants' career interests; men were clearly oriented toward "objects," and women were oriented toward "people." This may reinforce gender segregation processes, particularly by restricting women's career choices to fields that are less prestigious (Imdorf, Hegna, Eberhard, & Doray, 2015).…”

Diversity begets diversity: A global perspective on gender equality in scientific society leadership

“…We expect that such commitments will have a positive effect on promoting gender diversity. We also considered the geographical scope of the society, as biases in the perception of whether science is gendered tend to be predicted by national culture [ 12 , 13 ]. Thus, we might predict that societies with a more international reach may be more likely to demonstrate gender equality in leadership, and that gender representation varies with the geographic region of a society.…”

Adult Vocational Qualifications Reduce the Social Gradient in Education

“…The gender patterns relate to gender segregation in the Norwegian education system and labor market. Gender segregation in the education system seems to be stronger in systems with strong vocational education principles linked to occupational labor markets (Imdorf, Hegna, & Reizel, 2015). In Norway, men choose VET and apprenticeships to a higher degree than women who more often go on to higher education as adults.…”