The central question addressed in this study was whether upper class, suburban teenagers can engage in various problem behaviors and still maintain adequate academic grades, because of environmental safety nets, unlike their low-income, inner-city counterparts. Three problem behavior dimensions were assessed among tenth graders, that is, substance use, delinquency, and low school engagement. Academic achievement was assessed in terms of grades across four major subjects. Variable-based analyses indicated unique links with grades for self-reported delinquency and school disengagement in high-and low-income samples, but for substance use only among the former. Person-based analyses showed that in both schools, grades were clearly compromised among youth with disturbances in all three problem domains. In addition, in the suburban school only, grades were low in the cluster characterized chiefly by high substance use. Results are discussed in terms of stereotypes regarding risks (or lack thereof) stemming from families' socioeconomic status; implications for theory and interventions are also considered.In this study, the central objective was to explore the degree to which adolescent problem behaviors might have ramifications for academic grades in the context of affluent suburbia as opposed to inner-city poverty. On the one hand, there is some evidence that upper socioeconomic status (SES) youth can report as much maladjustment as their inner-city counterparts (if not more so) in areas such as delinquency and substance use. On the other hand, some have suggested that such behavior disturbances are unlikely to have any real ramifications for wealthy teens unlike their poor counterparts, given their vastly greater access to environmental safety nets. Exploration of this issue, vis-à-vis the outcome domain of academic grades, is at the heart of this paper. In discussions that follow, we outline the progression of research findings that culminated in questions addressed in this study.
Prior Evidence of Behavior Problems Among Affluent TeenagersIn the developmental psychopathology literature, evidence of high problems among affluent youth first appeared in research on substance use among teens from disparate sociodemographic backgrounds (Luthar & D'Avanzo, 1999). In preliminary descriptive analyses, the affluent, suburban students in this study were found to manifest surprisingly high maladjustment relative to the low-income, urban sample. To illustrate, they reported
HHS Public Access
Author Manuscript Author ManuscriptAuthor ManuscriptAuthor Manuscript significantly higher levels of using cigarettes, alcohol, marijuana, and other illicit drugs; they were also less likely to have abstained from substance use of any kind. Furthermore, they indicated equally high levels of delinquency as did youth in urban poverty, on an instrument encompassing incidents of theft, lying and cheating, destruction of property, and violence toward others (Self Report Delinquency;Elliot, Dunford, & Huizinga, 1987).Although these be...