Early warning signals of regime shifts in coupled human–environment systems

Abstract

In complex systems, a critical transition is a shift in a system's dynamical regime from its current state to a strongly contrasting state as external conditions move beyond a tipping point. These transitions are often preceded by characteristic early warning signals such as increased system variability. However, early warning signals in complex, coupled human-environment systems (HESs) remain little studied. Here, we compare critical transitions and their early warning signals in a coupled HES model to an equivalent environment model uncoupled from the human system. We parameterize the HES model, using social and ecological data from old-growth forests in Oregon. We find that the coupled HES exhibits a richer variety of dynamics and regime shifts than the uncoupled environment system. Moreover, the early warning signals in the coupled HES can be ambiguous, heralding either an era of ecosystem conservationism or collapse of both forest ecosystems and conservationism. The presence of human feedback in the coupled HES can also mitigate the early warning signal, making it more difficult to detect the oncoming regime shift. We furthermore show how the coupled HES can be "doomed to criticality": Strategic human interactions cause the system to remain perpetually in the vicinity of a collapse threshold, as humans become complacent when the resource seems protected but respond rapidly when it is under immediate threat. We conclude that the opportunities, benefits, and challenges of modeling regime shifts and early warning signals in coupled HESs merit further research.critical transitions | criticality | social-ecological systems | human-and-natural systems | early warning signal

Defining tipping points for social-ecological systems scholarship—an interdisciplinary literature review

“…These additional features could include Magnitude of Change (as well as Impact Severity), which is important to distinguish exceptional, infrequent but high-impact events, delineating tipping point change from other forms of change, and drawing policy attention. Work on Predictive Challenges is already progressing in SES with regard to early warning signals for regime shifts in ecosystems , Dakos et al 2012, Bauch et al 2016 and could be expanded to STPs.…”

The influence of social behaviour on competition between virulent pathogen strains

“…where k is the sampling rate and U is the payoff difference between the two strategies. This equation is derived elsewhere and is used in other socio-ecological and socioepidemiological models ( Bauch, 2005;Bauch et al, 2016;Henderson et al, 2016;Oraby et al, 2014 ). The augmented system of differential equations representing the coupled social-epidemiological SI 1 I 2 RX model with adaptive human behaviour is therefore given by:…”

Network parameters quantify loss of assemblage structure in human‐impacted lake ecosystems

“…Much research effort has been expended in the search for early warning signals of declining resilience and tipping points as measured in the frequency domain, such as critical slowing down and flickering (Scheffer et al, ). However, these remain contentious (Bauch, Sigdel, Pharaon, & Anand, ; Ditlevsen & Johnsen, ; Hastings & Wysham, ; Kéfi, Dakos, Scheffer, Van Nes, & Rietkerk, ) and prove elusive in ecological records constrained by sparse temporal data, high data noise and low resolution (Wang et al, ). In contrast, few studies of changes in ecosystem structure have measured the network domain, even though theory predicts that losses of ecosystem resilience should always be associated with structural changes in species associations (Scheffer et al, ; Strogatz, ).…”