Dynamic linear model and SARIMA: a comparison of their forecasting performance in epidemiology

Abstract

One goal of a public health surveillance system is to provide a reliable forecast of epidemiological time series. This paper describes a study that used data collected through a national public health surveillance system in the United States to evaluate and compare the performances of a seasonal autoregressive integrated moving average (SARIMA) and a dynamic linear model (DLM) for estimating case occurrence of two notifiable diseases. The comparison uses reported cases of malaria and hepatitis A from January 1980 to June 1995 for the United States. The residuals for both predictor models show that they were adequate tools for use in epidemiological surveillance. Qualitative aspects were considered for both models to improve the comparison of their usefulness in public health. Our comparison found that the two forecasting modelling techniques (SARIMA and DLM) are comparable when long historical data are available (at least 52 reporting periods). However, the DLM approach has some advantages, such as being more easily applied to different types of time series and not requiring a new cycle of identification and modelling when new data become available.

Estimation of Cancer Deaths in Korea for the Upcoming Years

“…The problem of choosing a forecast approach depends on the relative performance of the models for monitoring and prediction, with an adequate interpretation of the phenomenon under study (9). Since selection of the models could be based on the logarithm of the predictive likelihood error (10), this study used the R-square statistic and sigma types of observation in order to specify the degree of the time trend model.…”

Identification of the prediction model for dengue incidence in Can Tho city, a Mekong Delta area in Vietnam

“…A SARIMA model, using the Box and Jenkins approach which has been described elsewhere (Helfenstein, 1991;Allard, 1998;Nobre et al, 2001;Box et al, 1976;Ljung and Box, 1978), was developed using dengue incidence data from 2003 to 2010. Then the model was used to predict dengue incidence for the year 2011.…”

Forecasting mortality of road traffic injuries in China using seasonal autoregressive integrated moving average model

“…In this study, a SARIMA model was developed using seasonality of road traffic deaths as the independent variable and monthly road traffic deaths as the dependent variable. The most general SARIMA model with S observations per period, denoted by SARIMA (p, d, q) (P, D, Q) S , has the following form [17]:…”