Dynamic life cycle carbon and energy analysis for cross-laminated timber in the Southeastern United States

Abstract

Life cycle assessment (LCA) has been used to understand the carbon and energy implications of manufacturing and using cross-laminated timber (CLT), an emerging and sustainable alternative to concrete and steel. However, previous LCAs of CLT are static analyses without considering the complex interactions between the CLT manufacturing and forest systems, which are dynamic and largely affected by the variations in forest management, CLT manufacturing, and end-of-life options. This study fills this gap by developing a dynamic life-cycle modeling framework for a cradle-to-grave CLT manufacturing system across 100 years in the Southeastern United States. The framework integrates process-based simulations of CLT manufacturing and forest growth as well as Monte Carlo simulation to address uncertainty. On a 1-ha forest land basis, the net greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions range from −954 to −1445 metric tonne CO2 eq. for a high forest productivity scenario compared to −609 to −919 metric tonne CO2 eq. for a low forest productivity scenario. All scenarios showed significant GHG emissions from forest residues decay, demonstrating the strong needs to consider forest management and their dynamic impacts in LCAs of CLT or other durable wood products (DWP). The results show that using mill residues for energy recovery has lower fossil-based GHG (59%–61% reduction) than selling residues for producing DWP, but increases the net GHG emissions due to the instantaneous release of biogenic carbon in residues. In addition, the results were converted to a 1 m3 basis with a cradle-to-gate system boundary to be compared with literature. The results, 113–375 kg CO2 eq. m−3 across all scenarios for fossil-based GHG emissions, were consistent with previous studies. Those findings highlight the needs of system-level management to maximize the potential benefits of CLT. This work is an attributional LCA, but the presented results lay a foundation for future consequential LCAs for specific CLT buildings or commercial forest management systems.

Dynamic life-cycle carbon analysis for fast pyrolysis biofuel produced from pine residues: implications of carbon temporal effects

“…4 . The residues left on the forest land are prone to natural decay which emits GHG [ 78 ]. The dynamics of forest residues are complex and could be included in the future analysis as counterfactual scenarios.…”

Building Life-Cycle Analysis with the GREET Building Module: Methodology, Data, and Case Studies

“…Some EPDs, such as Portland Cement Association ( 2016), covered stucco together with other concrete products and only reported a consolidated result. As for research studies, Dodge & Liu (2018) compared the life cycle impacts According to Lan et al (2020), the Cradle-to-Gate GHG emissions of 1 m 3 cross-laminated lumber product produced is 113.1 --236.3 kg CO2 equivalent when using mill residues for energy recovery, and the that is 260.3 -375.4 kg CO2 equivalent when selling mill residues to produce wood products.…”

Circular utilization of urban tree waste contributes to the mitigation of climate change and eutrophication

“…They were selected based on their potential economic and environmental benefits discussed in the previous literature. 7,[17][18][19][20][21] LCA is a standardized and widely accepted tool to evaluate the environmental impacts of a product or a service throughout its life cycle. 17,[22][23][24][25][26] To explore the potential environmental benefits, counterfactual systems for alternative end-of-life cases were considered.…”