Does opportunity to learn explain the math score gap between madrasah and non-madrasah students in Indonesia?

Abstract

The opportunity to learn (OTL) is one of the important aspects of achieving the goal of the learning process. There have been three dimensions of OTL: instructional time (IT), content covered during instruction (CC), and quality of instruction (QI) mentioned in the literature and used as a framework in this article. This study aims to reveal the gap in math ability between madrasah and non-madrasah students in Indonesia and the contribution of the three OTL aspects toward math scores. This study employed a cross-sectional survey approach with self-report instruments. The data were obtained from a survey of participants in the New Students National Selection for Madrasah Aliyah Negeri (Islamic High-school managed by the ministry of religious affairs) in 2021. There were 8,258 participants, consisting of 4,842 students from madrasah and 3,416 from non-madrasah. This study used multilevel structural equation modeling (SEM) to analyze the data. The findings show that (a) there is a gap in math ability score between madrasah and non-madrasah students which is -27, with a mean math ability score of madrasah students being lower than non- madrasah students, and (b) the time invested in learning significantly affects the occurrence of gaps in math ability scores, while the scope of the materials and the quality of learning do not affect the occurrence of the gap in math ability scores. These findings suggest that it is important for the Ministry of Religious Affairs to consider the addition of mathematical lesson duration in madrasah while restructuring the allocation for Islamic lessons.

The Use of Stocking-Lord and Haebara Methods in Horizontal Equating: A Case of Indonesian Madrasah Competence Assessment

“…This change may imply a deliberate effort to fulfil a broader range of abilities or to introduce more variability in the questions tested based on this result. It is expected that diverse disparities in the abilities of madrasa students from all over Indonesia can be fully represented (Kusaeri & Aditomo, 2019;Umar et al, 2022).…”

“…Regarding trial participants, 2022 participants appear to be still experiencing shock due to the transition from online to offline learning, so they need an adjustment process. After they had experienced online learning for more than two years, there seemed to be a decline in various aspects, such as learning motivation, learning outcomes, and learning effectiveness (Umar et al, 2022). In the first year of online learning, there was a learning loss of 10-20%; in the second year, the learning loss improved to 70-80% (Lestari et al, 2023).…”

Exploring the Potential of Constructivist Pedagogical Approach in Strengthening Religious Moderation a Systematic Literature Review

“…In the Indonesian context, social, ethnic, and cultural diversity is considered a national asset that enriches society (Abror, 2020;Perdana, 2023;A. Umar et al, 2022).…”