Does cardiovascular preparticipation screening cause psychological distress in athletes? A systematic review

Abstract

ObjectiveTo evaluate the psychological implications of cardiovascular preparticipation screening (PPS) in athletes.DesignSystematic review.Data sourcesMEDLINE, EMBASE, PubMed, CINAHL, SPORTDiscus, APA PsycInfo, Cochrane Library and grey literature sources.Study eligibility criteriaObservational and experimental studies assessing a population of athletes who participated in a cardiovascular PPS protocol, where psychological outcomes before, during and/or after PPS were reported.MethodsResults of included studies were synthesised by consolidating similar study-reported measures for key psychological outcomes before, during and/or after screening. Summary measures (medians, ranges) were computed across studies for each psychological outcome.ResultsA total of eight studies were included in this review (median sample size: 479). Study cohorts consisted of high school, collegiate, professional and recreational athletes (medians: 59% male, 20.5 years). Most athletes reported positive reactions to screening and would recommend it to others (range 88%–100%, five studies). Increased psychological distress was mainly reported among athletes detected with pathological cardiac conditions and true-positive screening results. In comparison, athletes with false-positive screening results still reported an increased feeling of safety while participating in sport and were satisfied with PPS. A universal conclusion across all studies was that most athletes did not experience psychological distress before, during or after PPS, regardless of the screening modality used or accuracy of results.ConclusionPsychological distress associated with PPS in athletes is rare and limited to athletes with true-positive findings. To mitigate downstream consequences in athletes who experience psychological distress, appropriate interventions and resources should be accessible prior to the screening procedure.PROSPERO registration numberCRD42021272887.

Prevention of sport-related health issues

“…Jediná skupina sportovců, která prožívá po vyšetření negativní psychologickou zátěž, jsou jedinci s potvrzenou diagnózou. (17) Další vyšetřovací metody (např. echokardiografie, ergometrie) se v současné době v rámci screeningu NSS u sportovců paušálně nedoporučují.…”

Estratificação de risco cardiovascular no atleta jovem e veterano: questionário de pré-participação

“…A história clínica deteta mais anormalidades do que o exame físico (Lammlein et al, 2018), no entanto a maioria das alterações cardíacas associadas a um maior risco de MSC são sugestivas ou identificadas por anormalidades presentes no eletrocardiograma (ECG) de 12 derivações em repouso (Drezner et al, 2017), pelo que o uso deste exame como ferramenta de primeira linha é cada vez mais uma opção viável na deteção precoce de alterações cardíacas de risco de MSC em atletas, quando implementados nas avaliações físicas de pré-participação, acompanhando a normal avaliação física e preenchimento de questionário (Harmon et al, 2015a). (Solberg et al, 2012;Hill et al, 2023), embora uma pequena minoria desta população admita se sentir nervosa quando é examinada. Para atletas com reações negativas ao EMD, é imperativo que recursos apropriados sejam disponibilizados e exames de follow-up de rotina sejam realizados para mitigar possíveis consequências (Solberg et al, 2012).…”

Posicionamiento mexicano para el tamizaje y la evaluación cardiovascular preparticipación deportiva

“…La implementación de los protocolos de TECPD constituye un reto complejo, ya que requiere de la disponibilidad de médicos y técnicos altamente capacitados, una adecuada logística, además de la infraestructura social, cultural, financiera y legal correspondiente. Incluso debe considerar el estrés emocional que afecta a los atletas que son evaluados 15 .…”