Does a Single Session of High-Intensity Interval Training Provoke a Transient Elevated Risk of Falling in Seniors and Adults?

Abstract

Background: Balance and strength training can reduce seniors' fall risk up to 50%. Available evidence suggests that acute bouts of neuromuscular and endurance exercise deteriorate postural control. High-intensity endurance training has been successfully applied in different populations. Thus, it seemed valuable to examine the acute effects of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) on neuromuscular performance in seniors and young adults. Objective: The acute impact of a HIIT session on balance performance and muscle activity after exercise cessation and during post-exercise recovery was examined in young and old adults. We intended to investigate whether a transient exercise-induced fall-risk may occur in both groups. Methods: 20 healthy seniors (age 70 (SD 4) years) and young adults (age 27 (SD 3) years) were examined on 3 days. After exhaustive ramp-like treadmill testing in order to determine maximal heart rate (HR_max) on the first day, either a 4 × 4 min HIIT at 90% of HR_max or a control condition (CON) was randomly performed on the second and third day, respectively. Balance performance (postural sway) was assessed during single limb stance with open eyes (SLEO) and double limb stance with closed eyes (DLEC). EMG was recorded for the soleus (SOL), anterior tibialis (TIB), gastrocnemius (GM) and peroneus longus (PL) muscles at the dominant leg. All measures were collected before, immediately as well as 10, 30 and 45 min after HIIT and CON, respectively. Results: Compared to CON, HIIT induced significant increases of postural sway immediately after exercise cessation during SLEO in both groups (adults: p < 0.001, Δ = +25% sway; seniors: p = 0.007, Δ = +15% sway). Increased sway during DLEC was only found for seniors immediately and 10 min after HIIT (post: p = 0.003, Δ = +14% sway, 10 min post: p = 0.004, Δ = +18% sway). Muscle activity was increased during SLEO for TIB until 10 min post in seniors (0.008 < p < 0.03) and immediately after HIIT in adults (p < 0.001). Conclusion: HIIT training may cause an acute ‘open-fall-window' with a transient impairment of balance performance for at least 10 min after exercise cessation in both groups. Occluded vision in seniors seems to prolong this period up to 30 min. Thus, the advantage of HIIT with regard to time efficiency seems debatable when considering transient HIIT-induced impairments of neuromuscular function.

High-intensity interval training (HIIT) increases insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) in sedentary aging men but not masters’ athletes: an observational study

“…Moreover, Donath et al [31] reported increased postural sway following a single HIIT session in seniors (70 ± 3 years), suggesting an increased likelihood of falls acutely post-HIIT. As such, pragmatic periodization is necessary to allow adequate recovery and mitigate risk arising from HIIT [13].…”

Exercise-Based Fall Prevention in the Elderly: What About Agility?

“…Acute effects of aerobic activities during daily life might also adversely affect postural control, particularly in subjects with less aerobic capacity. There is evidence that fatigue resulting from moderate and heavy bicycle and walking exercise reduces balance performance in seniors [38][39][40]. Higher aerobic capacity, in turn, may attenuate acute exercise-induced declines of balance performance.…”

The effect of physical exhaustion on gait stability in young and older individuals

“…M a n u s c r i p t Introduction During human walking, fatigue can affect sensorimotor function and motor control in many ways. First, high intensity physical training was reported to lead to interfered mechanoreceptor function [1] which would cause deteriorated sensorimotor performance.…”