Do not attempt resuscitation orders at the emergency department of a teaching hospital

Abstract

ObjectiveTo identify factors associated with not attempting resuscitation.MethodsA cross-sectional study conducted at the emergency department of a teaching hospital. The sample consisted of 285 patients; in that, 216 were submitted to cardiopulmonary resuscitation and 69 were not. The data were collected by means of the in-hospital Utstein Style. To compare resuscitation attempts with variables of interest we used the χ2 test, likelihood ratio, Fisher exact test, and analysis of variance (p<0.05).ResultsNo cardiopulmonary resuscitation was considered unjustifiable in 56.5% of cases; in that, 37.7% did not want resuscitation and 5.8% were found dead. Of all patients, 22.4% had suffered a previous cardiac arrest, 49.1% were independent for Activities of Daily Living, 89.8% had positive past medical/surgical history; 63.8% were conscious, 69.8% were breathing and 74.4% had a pulse upon admission. Most events (76.4%) happened at the hospital, the presumed cause was respiratory failure in 28.7% and, in 48.4%, electric activity without pulse was the initial rhythm. The most frequent cause of death was infection. The factors that influenced non-resuscitation were advanced age, history of neoplasm and the initial arrest rhythm was asystole.ConclusionAdvanced age, past history of neoplasia and asystole as initial rhythm were factors that significantly influenced the non-performance of resuscitation. Greater clarity when making the decision to resuscitate patients can positively affect the quality of life of survivors.

Diretivas antecipadas de vontade em unidade de emergência hospitalar

“…Diretivas antecipadas de vontade em unidade de emergência hospitalar invasivos é sempre difícil para a equipe assistencial. A carência de pesquisas na área, a falta de clareza em reconhecer nuances nessas situações e as diferentes atitudes e valores pessoais de profissionais, familiares e pacientes são elementos que dificultam ainda mais este processo 16,34 .…”

“…Para os familiares, este tratamento pode acarretar falsas expectativas e custos elevados. Do ponto de vista da sociedade, este tipo de atendimento pode gerar consumo fútil de recursos 16 .…”

Terminality Advance Directives and Nursing Practice in Brazil: Bioethical Issues

“…Little is prepared for death. Even the health professionals are prepared to seek only life above all, putting death as something to be defeated [8]. In the situations where the medical behaviors are exhausted, the palliative care appears to offer better assistance to the patient and to minimize the suffering [9].…”

“…However, the lack of knowledge of regulations aimed at nursing professionals and the fear of ethical-legal implications interfere with the use of ADs. Faced with this reality and to avoid conflicts, nurses prefer to attend the wishes of family members, even if these wishes are not in accordance with the wishes expressed by the patient [27,8].…”

Palliative care in the pre-hospital service in Brazil: experiences of health professionals

“…Due to the understanding of these professionals that the role of the service is to treat acute symptoms and stabilize the patient, they resort to extraordinary measures in patients eligible for PC, such as cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and other invasive and futile procedures. In Brazil, Non-resuscitation Orders (NRO) are not supported by legislation, which requires health professionals to apply CPR in all cases, except when death is unquestionable [ 16 ], causing an increase in hospitalizations and prolongation of the patient’s suffering and their family members.…”