Disrupting evolutionary processes: The effect of habitat fragmentation on collared lizards in the Missouri Ozarks

Abstract

Humans affect biodiversity at the genetic, species, community, and ecosystem levels. This impact on genetic diversity is critical, because genetic diversity is the raw material of evolutionary change, including adaptation and speciation. Two forces affecting genetic variation are genetic drift (which decreases genetic variation within but increases genetic differentiation among local populations) and gene flow (which increases variation within but decreases differentiation among local populations). Humans activities often augment drift and diminish gene flow for many species, which reduces genetic variation in local populations and prevents the spread of adaptive complexes outside their population of origin, thereby disrupting adaptive processes both locally and globally within a species. These impacts are illustrated with collared lizards (Crotaphytus collaris) in the Missouri Ozarks. Forest fire suppression has reduced habitat and disrupted gene flow in this lizard, thereby altering the balance toward drift and away from gene flow. This balance can be restored by managed landscape burns. Some have argued that, although human-induced fragmentation disrupts adaptation, it will also ultimately produce new species through founder effects. However, population genetic theory and experiments predict that most fragmentation events caused by human activities will facilitate not speciation, but local extinction. Founder events have played an important role in the macroevolution of certain groups, but only when ecological opportunities are expanding rather than contracting. The general impact of human activities on genetic diversity disrupts or diminishes the capacity for adaptation, speciation, and macroevolutionary change. This impact will ultimately diminish biodiversity at all levels.

Habitat selection and ecological speciation in Galápagos warbler finches ( Certhidea olivacea and Certhidea fusca )

“…The role of habitat remained cryptic until this comprehensive analysis of 16 discrete island populations. This study provides an example of the need to carefully assess the biodiversity value of small populations (Blondel et al 1999;Templeton et al 2001). Small, peripheral populations that do not appear to be unique may nevertheless harbour biologically significant variation that may play an important role in evolution.…”

The current biodiversity extinction event: Scenarios for mitigation and recovery

“…Such putatively secured habitats may be vulnerable to many threats, such as population fragmentation of keystone species, disruption of biogeochemical cycles, or invasive species. One of the most disruptive factors to community stability is the interference with a balance of evolutionary processes, such as genetic drift and gene flow, that ensure genetic variation in species (33).…”

The biotic crisis and the future of evolution

“…These first-order impacts will likely engender a series of further consequences, including although not limited to: (i) fragmentation of species' ranges, with disruption of gene flow (25)(26)(27)(28); (ii) decline in effective population sizes, with depletion of gene reservoirs͞pools (12,29,30); and (iii) biotic interchanges introducing species and even biotas into new areas, with multiple founder effects and novel competitive and other ecological interactions (13,16,31). These impacts, in turn, might disrupt food chains͞webs, symbioses, or other biological associations (32,33).…”