Discussing State‐of‐the‐Art Spatial Visualization Techniques Applicable for the Epidemiological Surveillance Data on the Example of Campylobacter spp. in Raw Chicken Meat

Abstract

Within the European activities for the 'Monitoring and Collection of Information on Zoonoses', annually EFSA publishes a European report, including information related to the prevalence of Campylobacter spp. in Germany. Spatial epidemiology becomes here a fundamental tool for the generation of these reports, including the representation of prevalence as an essential element. Until now, choropleth maps are the default visualization technique applied in epidemiological monitoring and surveillance reports made by EFSA and German authorities. However, due to its limitations, it seems to be reasonable to explore alternative chart type. Four maps including choropleth, cartogram, graduated symbols and dot-density maps were created to visualize real-world sample data on the prevalence of Campylobacter spp. in raw chicken meat samples in Germany in 2011. In addition, adjacent and coincident maps were created to visualize also the associated uncertainty. As an outcome, we found that there is not a single data visualization technique that encompasses all the necessary features to visualize prevalence data alone or prevalence data together with their associated uncertainty. All the visualization techniques contemplated in this study demonstrated to have both advantages and disadvantages. To determine which visualization technique should be used for future reports, we recommend to create a dialogue between end-users and epidemiologists on the basis of sample data and charts. The final decision should also consider the knowledge and experience of end-users as well as the specific objective to be achieved with the charts.

Spatiotemporal analysis of dengue fever in Nepal from 2010 to 2014

“…Due to availability of data in some sort of spatial aggregation, choropleth mapping technique is popular in disease mapping compared to dot map or isopleths map [33, 38]. Aggregated data is either directly plotted in the map or rate of incidence is computed using base population and level of spatial aggregation.…”

Spatiotemporal Distribution and Geospatial Diffusion Patterns of 2013 Dengue Outbreak in Jhapa District, Nepal

“…These techniques were also applied to other mosquito-borne infectious disease to map distribution, assess clusters, and examine the diffusion patterns earlier. 7,11 Choropleth mapping technique, the most popular of the methods in disease mapping 14,21 for aggregated data, was used to visualize the outbreak. The spatial distribution was found to be uneven with the substantial variation in the incidence rate.…”

“…Choropleth mapping technique, the most popular of the methods in disease mapping 14,21 for aggregated data, was used to visualize the outbreak. The spatial distribution was found to be uneven with the substantial variation in the incidence rate.…”

“…We used choropleth mapping technique to visualize the disease incidence rate. 14 We first prepared a choropleth map using absolute number of dengue cases. Then we computed a raw rate map to account for the risk level of population, taking the total population of respective ward as the base population.…”

Review of visual analytics methods for food safety risks

“…A cartogram can replace the real area of a region with the size of an attribute value and then distort and deform the geographic region to reflect quantitative characteristics more intuitively 93 . Plaza-Rodrıguez et al 94 used a cartogram to analyze the spatial distribution of the detection rates of Campylobacter spp. in retail raw chicken meat in Germany (Fig.…”