Differentiation and financial performance: a meta-analysis

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this study is to meta-analytically compare the effect of differentiation strategy formulation on financial and non-financial performance to explore the agency problem. Design/methodology/approach This study was conducted using a meta-analysis approach and CMA2 software. Hypotheses has been tested using cumulative effect sizes. Then, the cumulative effect sizes if some subsamples are also tested for robustness check by manipulation of circumstances. Findings Based on the findings, differentiation affects performance dimensions. However, spite of shareholders’ wealth maximization, differentiation has a smaller effect on financial performance (as the proxy of shareholders’ wealth) compared with operational performance. Meanwhile, the robustness test showed that the results in all subcategories has also confirmed, and this supports the results. Research limitations/implications The results catch attentions of shareholders to review the elements of management evaluation in the corporate governance system in a way that they focus more on stakeholders’ interests in developing differentiation strategy. Limitations of this study is firstly based on limitations of meta-analysis approach, which provide general results of relevant studies so that the local conditions of each firm should be considered in deploying implications. Originality/value Exploring the overall schema of firms (from past to present and in different research conditions) regarding the impact of differentiation strategy on performance has been the originality of this research because of potentials of meta-analysis against past field studies. This originality led to the discovery of the general confusion of firms in the development of differentiation strategy so that it emphasizes operational performance more than financial performance.

The Impact of Entrepreneurial Orientation on SMEs’ Performance in a Transitional Economy: The Mediating Role of Differentiation Advantages and Innovation Capability

“…Organizations striving for superior performance can be beneficial thanks to DA (M. Porter, 1985). Therefore, a review (see Banker et al, 2014) and a metaanalysis (see Mohammadi et al, 2019) strongly support that differentiation strategy aiming to gain DA permits the sustainability of financial performance.…”

Innovative Business Strategies in the Face of COVID-19: An Approach to Open Innovation of SMEs in the Sonora Region of Mexico

“…This variable was measured in a multidimensional way with theoretical support in the models of the OECD [105] and Teece [106] as the superior strategy and key factor in detonating business capabilities in order to generate greater competitiveness and profitability [11]. The evaluation and analysis of problems can improve innovation processes and capacities [107]; a company that seeks to follow this strategy must participate in the development of new processes and propose an integrated offer of products and services to create value between companies and their customers [108].…”

Bibliometric analysis of global research trends on microfinance institutions and microfinance: Suggesting new research agendas

“…Since the authors are using bibliometric analysis therefore, this study is different from all the normal systematic review or meta‐analysis studies due to the nature and presentation of the bibliometric analysis. For instance, some of the literature review articles, both from microfinance and microfinance institutions are obtained from previous research (Asongu & Nwachukwu, 2018; Atan & Johari, 2017; Bahoo, 2020; Hartarska & Holtmann, 2006; Hermes & Hudon, 2018; Hoda & Gupta, 2015; Karlan et al, 2014; Kim et al, 2018; Madhani et al, 2015; Marr et al, 2016; Mohammadi et al, 2019; Muhammad, 2010; Nasir, 2013; O'Malley & Burke, 2017; Orton et al, 2016; Primiana et al, 2018; Reichert, 2018; Van Rooyen et al, 2012). In contrast, this study provides hotspots such as financial technology including fintech, crowdfunding, data mining and financial literacy as emerging and new avenues for future research agenda.…”