Refer to the correspondence from Prof. Metzger about our previous publication on "Carbon-Centered Radical Addition to O=Co fA mides or Esters as aR oute to CÀOB ondF ormations", we wouldl ike to express some of our understandings herein.We mentionedi no ur paper that "Another possibility is CÀO bond formation through carbon-centered radical addition to carbonyl groups,i nw hich an ew carbon-centered radicali s generated( Scheme 1, Path B). There are relativelyf ew reports on the latter case of radical addition process, in which only aldehydea nd ketone have been applied as the carbonyl source [Eq. (1)]." [1] Theser eports suggested the possibility of CÀO bond forming through carbon-centered radical addition to aldehydec arbonylg roups. Furthermore, Kende et al. reported an abnormalp hoto-Fries rearrangement reactiono fa ryl phthalantes,i nw hich ac arbon-centered radical addition to carbonyl group of esters was suggested (Scheme 1). [2] Although Eguchi et al. have calculated that the cyclization in the conjugated system might be due to the conjugation effect with an onradical cyclization mechanism,t he addition of carbon-centered radicalt ocarbonyl groupi nanon-conjugateds ystem has not been ruled out. [3] In 1964, Menapace et al. demonstrateda na lkyl radicala ddition to the carbonyl of ketone to generate at etrahydrofuran derivative( Scheme2), suggesting that ac arbon-centeredr adi-cal addition to the ketone carbonyl group to form CÀOb ond is possible. [4] Moreover,N ishikatah as published as eries of papers on the Cu-catalyzed reactions between a-bromoe sters/amides and olefinss ince 2013, [5] whicha re consistent with our publications on the Ni-catalyzed reactionsb etween a-bromoe sters/amides and olefins. [1,6] In their recentp ublication on the selective formationo fl actam or iminolactone from the reaction between a-bromoa mides and electron-deficient olefins, [5c] they mentionedthat:" Conversely,t he intermediate B under weakly basic conditions undergoes radical cyclization to produce E. According to previousr eports,a mide oxygens favorably react with carbocations. However,t he generation of an a-carbocation from B by oxidation with aC u II species is considered to be unfavorable due to stability issues. Therefore,t he addition of a carbon-centered radicals pecies to ac arbonyl group is another reactionp athway and is at ypical radicalr eaction. Finally,i minolactone 4 is obtained after the oxidation of E with Cu II followedb yp rotonelimination" (Scheme3). [5c] Our cyclizationpaper was cited to explaint heir experimental observations. Furthermore, there is ac ommenti nt he correspondence of Prof. Metzgert hat "Amazingly,t he same authors reported in 2012 on the addition of the same or similar a-bromo esters and amides to the same or similar styrenes yielding 3-unsaturated esters and amides using the same catalyst and very similar reactionc onditions to those given in Scheme 2w ithout step 2a si nr eactions( 2) and (3)-namelyw ithout heatingt he reactionm ixture with acid and water."T his commenti su n...