Differences in clerkship development between public and private Brazilian medical schools: an overview

Abstract

Background Around the world, it is very expensive to become a physician. Although public medical schools are less expensive than private medical schools, tuition fees are charged at public medical schools in the majority of countries. In Brazil, public medical schools, with the exception of municipal schools, are free. There has been little investigation of any differences in conditions offered by paid or free medical schools or what occurs in public and private clerkships in Brazil. We investigated the clerkship conditions offered to the students in both public and private Brazilian medical schools by gathering the opinions of clerkship coordinators and others responsible for clerkships. Methods A cross-sectional, descriptive, analytical study using an electronic questionnaire was answered by clerkship coordinators to compare the clerkships of 30 public and 38 private Brazilian medical schools from all regions of the country. The questionnaires covered various aspects of the clinical environments, student supervision, faculty development, student assessments, rotation evaluations and extracurricular activities developed by students. Results We observed significant differences between public and private medical schools in several aspects investigated. Based on the opinions of the clerkship coordinators, with the exception of access to university hospitals, which was predominantly offered by public medical schools, private medical schools offer better clerkship conditions. The main differences were related to the number of positions, infrastructure, clinical learning environments, faculty development, student assessments, rotation evaluations and students’ extracurricular activities. Conclusion This is the first study comparing Brazilian medical clerkships in private and public medical schools and provides a general vision of these programmes. It is necessary to further investigate clerkship development in the Brazilian medical school system and to study the differences between private and public medical schools globally.

Perception of newly graduated physicians toward ethical education in medical schools: a Brazilian cross-sectional nationwide study

“…There is only one study in the literature comparing medical clerkships in public and private medical schools in Brazil 18 . Access to high-complexity university hospitals was predominantly offered by public medical schools.…”

Effects of individual and organizational factors on job tenure of primary care physicians: A multilevel analysis from Brazil

“…It is also worth questioning whether the curriculum guidance for medical schools, which very often focuses on surgery and specialized areas, is far removed from PHC and the most urgent health needs of the population [ 35 , 37 , 40 , 41 ]. Although curricular content may encourage students to choose to serve in PHC in the future [ 18 , 42 ], PHC is still underrepresented in medical school curricula [ 43 ].…”

Quem são e onde estão os médicos formados pela residência do Hospital das Clínicas da Universidade de São Paulo?

“…Analyzing the reasons for the higher number of students from public medical schools at the HCFMUSP MR, one of the hypotheses is the fact that part of the criteria for admission to the HCFMUSP MR is the analysis of the curriculum vitae, in which the university of the candidates is scored 17 . In this sense, public medical schools usually tend to have better evaluations, as they have more university hospitals of their own for the development of teaching, research, and assistance when compared to most private medical schools 18 .…”