Determinants of ethnic differences in the uptake of child healthcare services in New Zealand: a decomposition analysis

Abstract

Background There are persistent ethnic gaps in uptake of child healthcare services in New Zealand (NZ), despite increasing policy to promote equitable access. We examined ethnic differences in the uptake of immunisation and primary healthcare services at different ages and quantified the contribution of relevant explanatory factors, in order to identify potential points of intervention. Methods We used data from the Growing Up in New Zealand birth cohort study, including children born between 2009 and 2010. Econometric approaches were used to explore underlying mechanisms behind ethnic differences in service uptake. Multivariable regression was used to adjust for mother, child, household, socioeconomic, mobility, and social factors. Decomposition analysis was used to assess the proportion of each ethnic gap that could be explained, as well as the main drivers behind the explained component. These analyses were repeated for four data time-points. Results Six thousand eight hundred twenty-two mothers were enrolled during the antenatal survey, and children were followed up at 9-months, 2-years and 4-years. In univariable models, there were ethnic gaps in uptake of immunisation and primary care services. After adjusting for covariates in multivariable models, compared to NZ Europeans, Asian and Pacific children had higher timeliness and completeness of immunisation at all time-points, while indigenous Māori had lower timeliness of first-year vaccines despite high intentions to immunise. Asian and Pacific mothers were less likely to have their first-choice lead maternity caregiver (LMC) than NZ Europeans mothers, and Māori and Asian mothers were less likely to be satisfied with their general practitioner (GP) at 2-years. Healthcare utilisation was strongly influenced by socio-economic, mobility and social factors including ethnic discrimination. In decomposition models comparing Māori to NZ Europeans, the strongest drivers for timely first-year immunisations and GP satisfaction (2-years) were household composition and household income. Gaps between Pacific and NZ Europeans in timely first-year immunisations and choice of maternity carer were largely unexplained by factors included in the models. Conclusions Ethnic gaps in uptake of child healthcare services vary by ethnicity, service, and time-point, and are driven by different factors. Addressing healthcare disparities will require interventions tailored to specific ethnic groups, as well as addressing underlying social determinants and structural racism. Gaps that remain unexplained by our models require further investigation.

“I haven't even taken them to the doctors, because I have that fear of what to expect”: a qualitative description study exploring perceptions and experiences of early childhood healthcare among ethnically diverse caregivers in Aotearoa New Zealand

“…Another significant finding was that when families experienced ethnic discrimination, this was associated with reduced satisfaction levels, and childhood immunisations. 20 , 22 This is consistent with other substantive research that finds that racism and ethnic discrimination are determinants of inequitable immunisation coverage and healthcare access for children and their whānau (family). 23 , 24 , 25 …”

“… 16 A quantitative analyses using the GUiNZ study cohort of the uptake of early childhood services showed time-variant differences in the association between ethnicity and child immunisation indicators. 20 , 22 For example, socio-economic deprivation was a significant factor for families not having timely immunisations in the first year of the child's life, but not at the 15-months and 4-year old immunisation events. 20 This suggests that there are socio-economic drivers in the first year of life affect timely access to healthcare.…”

Exploring the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on perceptions of national scheduled childhood vaccines among Māori and Pacific caregivers, whānau, and healthcare professionals in Aotearoa New Zealand

“…Over the past 40 years, a mana-enhancing paradigm has substantially developed with application to various disciplines, including social work, health, and education. 51 Research has noted how HCP recommendations can influence vaccine decisions 15 , 52 and how the COVID-19 pandemic can provide an opportune time for immunization providers to support informed vaccine decision-making among parents. 9 As such, there is the opportunity for HCPs to engage in respectful and mana-enhancing discussions with whānau about vaccines and support intergenerational conversations for collective decision-making.…”

Rising Kawasaki disease incidence in New Zealand: analysis of national population incidence and outcomes 2000–2017

“…Non-genetic factors however may be more important. Recent research suggests socioeconomic status, mobility and discrimination are strong influences for many health outcomes in Māori 37…”