Destigmatising the stigma: Understanding the impact of message framing on Chinese consumers' guilt and attitude associated with overspending behaviour

Abstract

Overspending has been a largely stigmatised consumer behaviour in traditional Chinese culture. However, social and economic development in recent decades has induced the rise of Chinese consumerism and changes in public attitudes towards overspending. Focusing on overspending stigmas Gouwukuang (GWK) and Duoshoudang (DSD) and stigma‐relevant attitudes, the present study investigates the effect of perceived stigma on consumers' attitude towards overspending through the mediating effect of anticipated consumer guilt. The moderating role of message framing in this relationship is also examined. Results of two analyses indicate that (a) between the two stigmas, DSD is less stigmatising and preferred in comparison to GWK in social interaction and self‐identification; (b) participants' perception of the stigma associated with overspending predicts their anticipation of guilt associated with this behaviour, which in turn predicts negative attitude towards overspending; (c) message framing moderates the relationship between perceived stigma and anticipated guilt, and hence facilitates destigmatisation of the traditionally stigmatised behaviour of overspending. Theoretical and practical implications of these findings are discussed.

The influence of Internet shopping and use of credit cards on gender differences in compulsive buying

“…The reasons for feelings of regret in compulsive buyers are numerous: It may be regret about the loss of money, debt or fears of conflict in relationships. However, the feeling of lack of control over compulsive buying tendencies remains central to feelings of regret (Lee and Workman, 2018) and guilt (Fan et al, 2020) in compulsive buyers. All these aspects may, in turn, initiate further extensive buying in order to continue to cope with such negative aversion feelings.…”

Prevalence of Suicidal Behavior and Associated Clinical Correlates in Patients with Behavioral Addictions

“…Even though suicide is a complex multi-factorial phenomenon [ 75 ], there is large literature pointing out that feelings of shame and guilt are relevant drives for committing a suicidal act [ 55 , 56 ]. In addition, stigma has been reported to be particularly predominant in these disorders [ 76 , 77 , 78 ] and the former has been described as a trigger for suicidality [ 79 ]. The high prevalence of suicidal behavior in these three disorders constitute a relevant finding from the present study.…”

Systematizing destigmatization in the context of media and communication: a systematic literature review

“…Nevertheless, Kosenko et al (2019) mention that this sociological definition of stigma is also criticized-as being both too narrow and too broad. A lot of publications in this SLR's final sample include both the definitions of stigma by Goffman (1963) and Link and Phelan (2001) (e.g., Chung and Slater, 2013;Dassieu et al, 2021;Fan et al, 2021;Roscoe, 2021;Liu and Kozinets, 2022). Kosenko et al (2019) then suggest that stigma should be defined as communication-based, so that "stigma is outside of the individual and to emphasize its discursive nature" (p. 4).…”