Deserted Islands and Overwhelmed Readers

Lee, Maurice S.

doi:10.1093/alh/aju001

Cited by 3 publications

(2 citation statements)

References 1 publication

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…This anti-explorer's island, with its myriad seashells and other forms that recursively plunge into a corrugated abyss, dashes the aspirations of would-be close readers who fantasize of a "shipwreck" and a "deserted island" where they might "enjoy some close reading, " peacefully and simply, far from the maddening and "inconceivable quantity of texts" long available in libraries and archives and, now, "from electronic databases. " 116 Rather than offering an idyllic return to close reading, the anti-explorer's island is a maelstrom, a place constituted by infinitely large numbers of analytical frames moving toward the infinitely minute, matching and even exceeding the sheer capaciousness of what Franco Moretti, beginning in the year 2000, has described as "distant reading. " 117 Approaching this island brings us closer to what is both Introduction | 29 unknowable and unscalable in the Real.…”

Section: Thinking With the Island: A Nissology Of The Anti-explorer Amentioning

confidence: 99%

Introduction

Roberts¹,

Stephens²

Archipelagic American Studies

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Every grade-schooler in the United States is taught to view President Thomas Jefferson's 1803 Louisiana Purchase as a landmark event in "American history. " This purchase, as the famous narrative goes, doubled the size of the United States and ousted France (and the threat of its power ful army) from continental North Amer i ca. 1 But consider the Louisiana Purchase's fame in comparison to that of the United States' nearly forgotten 1941 agreement to build military bases on six British colonial possessions in the Ca rib bean, which President Franklin D. Roo se velt trumpeted as "the most impor tant action in the reinforcement of our national defense. .. since the Louisiana Purchase. " 2 Or consider the Louisiana Purchase side by side with President Harry S. Truman's seldom-discussed Cold War instigation of a US trusteeship in Micronesia, which more than doubled the size of the United States in terms of total land and water area, thereby constituting a massive geo graph i cal grounding for its emergence as the dominant Pacific power (see figure I.1). 3 Juxtaposing the Louisiana Purchase's fame with these enormously significant yet comparatively unknown events in the Ca rib bean and Pacific, one must ask how the narrative of continental Amer i ca (which has been a geo graph i cal story central to US historiography and self-conception) has so completely eclipsed the narrative of what we are terming "the archipelagic Ameri cas, " or the temporally shifting and spatially splayed set of islands, island chains, and island-ocean-continent relations which have exceeded US-Americanism and have been affiliated with and indeed constitutive of competing notions of the Amer i cas since at least 1492. This archipelagic version of Amer i ca has spanned more than five centuries, and hence the archipelagic Amer i cas are clearly not confined to the islands and waters that have been appropriated by the United States via (to borrow a phrase from Richard Drinnon) the United States' dedication to "seagoing Manifest Destiny. " 4 Yet within the interdisciplinary field of American studies (which has Introduction | 3 ism is of a piece with postexceptionalist American studies' more general treatments of island-based US territories in the Pacific and Ca rib be an, 9 and as an upshot of this anti-imperialist and postcolonial tack, transnational American studies has increasingly tended to highlight a view of the United States as imbricated with insular and archipelagic spaces. Consider, as a litmus test, the presence or absence of the term "archipelago" within the American Studies Association's official journal, American Quarterly, from its founding in 1949 through the pres ent. Whereas the half century ranging from 1949 through 1999 saw only six articles that used the term "archipelago, " the first fifteen years of the twenty-first century saw thirty-eight articles using the term. 10 And indeed, the journal's 2014 and 2015 special issues, respectively titled Las Américas Quarterly and Pacific Currents, both offer content that not only addres...

show abstract

Section: Thinking With the Island: A Nissology Of The Anti-explorer Amentioning

confidence: 99%

Introduction

Roberts¹,

Stephens²

Archipelagic American Studies

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Th is anti-explorer's island, with its myriad seashells and other forms that recursively plunge into a corrugated abyss, dashes the aspirations of would-be close readers who fantasize of a "shipwreck" and a "deserted island" where they might "enjoy some close reading, " peacefully and simply, far from the maddening and "inconceivable quantity of texts" long available in libraries and archives and, now, "from electronic databases. " 116 Rather than off ering an idyllic return to close reading, the anti-explorer's island is a maelstrom, a place constituted by infi nitely large numbers of analytical frames moving toward the infi nitely minute, matching and even exceeding the sheer capaciousness of what Franco Moretti, beginning in the year 2000, has described as "distant reading. " 117 Approaching this island brings us closer to what is both Introduction | 29 unknowable and unscalable in the Real.…”

Section: Introduction | 23mentioning

confidence: 99%