Deregulation, Bank Competition and Regional Growth

Abstract

CARBÓ VALVERDE S., HUMPHREY D. B. and RODRÍGUEZ FERNÁ NDEZ F. (2003)Deregulation, bank competition and regional growth, Reg. Studies 37, 227-237. Cross-country studies suggest that countries with greater financial sector competition have higher rates of economic growth. However, it is difficult to 'hold constant' different legal and cultural environments in these analyses, leading some to suggest that this relationship is due less to competition than to differing legal and cultural conditions which favour economic growth. As these differences are small within a country, an interregional analysis may reflect better the relationship between financial market competition and growth. We study five large regions in Spain over 1986-98. Using different indicators of market competition, we analyse changes in regional competition and growth. Granger-causality tests show that differences in competition are not associated with improved regional growth. Although deregulation raised deposit rates and lowered loan rates, these benefits have not markedly influenced regional growth. The positive relationship shown between competitive markets and growth in cross-country studies may instead be due to some unspecified third factor that influences both. DeregulationMarket

Multimarket Contact and Profitability in Banking: Evidence from Italy

“…This is an acknowledged approach in studies regarding European countries when disaggregated balance-sheet data are not available. Among the others, seeMaudos (1998), CarboValverde et al (2003), andDegryse and Ongena (2005).11 In the formula, c il and c jl act as indicator functions that allow to identify the markets where the two banks meet. 12 Suppose that banks i and j meet in 3 markets, and that in each of them bank i's market share is close to 1 while bank j's market share is close to 0.…”

Banking Market Structure, Creation and Activity of Firms: Early Evidence for Cooperatives in the Italian Case

“…3 Since in Italy (like in most European countries) data at local banking office level are not publicly available, by following Carbò Valverde et al (2003), and Agostino and Trivieri (forthcoming), each variable x needed in the computation of the HHI indicator is drawn as:…”

An investigation on the causal relationships between banking concentration and economic growth

“…To our knowledge, the only empirical analysis that has tried to explore the causality links between banking market competition and economic growth through a Granger-causality test within the same country (in order to hold constant differences in legal and cultural environments) is the paper by Carbo Valverde et al (2003). As a matter of fact, our framework differs from theirs under a variety of aspects.…”

“…The choice of the variable representing the market concentration has revealed much harder. As Carbo Valverde et al (2003) also note, unlike the US, information on the value of deposits, loans or assets at a regional level are not publicly available in most European countries, including Italy. In order to overcome this lack of disaggregated data, some authors use the regional distribution of branch offices (which is known), therefore presuming that a bank having 30% of branches in a market also holds a 30% share of deposits (or loans, or assets) market share.…”