Delivery of alcohol brief interventions in community-based youth work settings: exploring feasibility and acceptability in a qualitative study

Abstract

BackgroundAlcohol Brief Interventions (ABIs) are increasingly being delivered in community-based youth work settings. However, little attention has been paid to how they are being implemented in such settings, or to their feasibility and acceptability for practitioners or young people. The aim of this qualitative study was to explore the context, feasibility and acceptability of ABI delivery in youth work projects across Scotland.MethodsIndividual, paired and group interviews were conducted with practitioners and young people in nine community projects that were either involved in the delivery of ABIs or were considering doing so in the near future. A thematic analysis approach was used to analyse data.ResultsABIs were delivered in a diverse range of youth work settings including the side of football pitches, on the streets as part of outreach activities, and in sexual health drop-in centres for young people. ABI delivery differed in a number of important ways from delivery in other health settings such as primary care, particularly in being largely opportunistic and flexible in nature. ABIs were adapted by staff in line with the ethos of their project and their own roles, and to avoid jeopardising their relationships with young people. Young people reacted positively to the idea of having conversations about alcohol with youth project workers, but confirmed practitioners’ views about the importance of these conversations taking place in the context of an existing trusting relationship.ConclusionABIs were feasible in a range of youth work settings with some adaptation. Acceptability to staff was strongly influenced by perceived benefits, and the extent to which ABIs fitted with their project’s ethos. Young people were largely comfortable with such conversations. Future implementation efforts should be based on detailed consideration of current practice and contexts. Flexible models of delivery, where professional judgement can be exercised over defined but adaptable content, may be better appreciated by staff and encourage further development of ABI activity.

Discussing alcohol in medicines use reviews: experiences of patients in a community pharmacy context

“…The findings show that patterns of alcohol consumption are culturally located and sometimes endemic in working practices. Therefore, interventions need to be appropriately positioned, with advice making sense within patients’ cultural contexts. Future research should work with deprived communities to develop culturally meaningful information resources, conveyed through respected channels and within pertinent environments.…”

‘DrinkThink’ alcohol screening and brief intervention for young people: a qualitative evaluation of training and implementation

“… 50 Community-based agencies are more likely to see young people with health-related problems 8 , 51 , 52 and are therefore crucial to the delivery process. 23 …”

Extending alcohol brief advice into non-clinical community settings: a qualitative study of experiences and perceptions of delivery staff

“…In the UK, health policy support for the increased opportunistic implementation of IBAs in primary care has also been extended into secondary care and other health care settings [4]. Implementation of IBAs in alternative community settings, including social care, criminal justice and the community and voluntary sectors are also becoming more common [15–20] and is supported by national guidelines There has been considerable interest in community pharmacy, in particular, as an appropriate setting for the delivery of IBA in light of community pharmacists’ increasing role in public health and health promotion as well as their accessibility, particularly in areas of high deprivation [21, 22]. There is growing evidence to support the feasibility and acceptability of this setting for the delivery of IBA from both public and practitioner perspectives [23–25].…”