Delivering Bad News to Patients: Survey of Physicians, Patients, and Their Family Members’ Attitudes

Abstract

Background: Breaking bad news to patients is an unpleasant process, but it is essential for the medical team, which is giving information about a person’s illness; without proper planning, it leads to a negative impact on people’s feelings and quality of life. Cultural differences can be effective in telling bad news. Objectives: This study aimed to identify the attitudes of physicians, patients, and patients’ families towards breaking bad medical news. Methods: This cross-sectional study was performed among physicians, patients, and their families referred to Namazi Hospital, Shiraz, Iran, during 2016 - 2017. Their attitudes regarding how to tell bad news were evaluated by self-administrated questionnaires. Results: A total of 397 valid questionnaires completed by physicians, patients, and their families were analyzed in this study. All groups of participants preferred telling bad news to patients about the diagnosis of their disease; they also believed that in the case of a patient’s dissatisfaction, this information should not be given to other family members. Patients’ family members would rather tell lies to the patient about their diagnosis. Conclusions: There is a tendency towards not telling bad news in Iranian culture; Iranian people tend to protect those around them, and the desire to give bad news to those around them is lower than the tendency to hear bad news about one’s own illness. With increasing education, the tendency to telling bad news increases.

Communication with cancer patients: the perspective of caregivers versus non-caregivers in Iran

“…Fourthly, it appears that families' expectations serve as a barrier to open and comprehensive communication between healthcare professionals and cancer patients. In Iran, the role of the family is paramount in handling bad news and providing care (Bazrafshan et al, 2022). In many cases, it is the family that determines how much patients are told, who delivers the information, and even when to transition from treatment to palliative care (Shah et al, 2023).…”

The role of family and culture in the disclosure of bad news: A multicentre cross-sectional study in Pakistan

“…In other parts of the world, the notion of collective autonomy applies often and consequently the patient will often defer to the family or the eldest in the family. Family member/s will often hide the truth in the context of bad news due to collective family wishes and the priority of avoiding perceived damage to patient health in many cultures [ [7] , [8] , [9] , [10] ]. Disregard for the cultural context and family during disclosure can make the experience of receiving the bad news even worse and can negatively impact the future experience of the patient and family with medical care.…”