Defining Conservation Strategies with Historical Perspectives: a Case Study from a Degraded Oak Grassland Ecosystem

Abstract

The restoration of degraded ecosystems can be constrained by uncertainty over former conditions and the relevance of the past given recent changes. It can be difficult to differentiate among contrasting hypotheses about past ecosystem function, and restoration efforts can emphasize species reestablishment without integrating the ecological and cultural processes that once determined their occurrence. As a case study, we analyzed historical descriptions of an endangered oak grassland ecosystem in southwestern British Columbia, Canada, to determine former conditions and assess their validity for defining restoration targets. Twenty-three documents described this ecosystem from 1790 to 1951. Comparison of early survey records with contemporary occurrences suggests habitat loss of >95%. The identity and former range of most native plant species were poorly described, but accounts of ecosystem structure revealed a diversity of floral communities that has been much simplified. Fire, most likely set by indigenous peoples, interacted with edaphic and topographic factors to create this structural diversity. European settlers intensively modified the ecosystem with grazing, cultivation, and introduced flora. These transformations partly explain the current high levels of plant invasion. Restoration must target the ecosystems' former structural diversity and the ecological and cultural processes that maintained it. Given the recent impacts of fire suppression, habitat loss, and plant invasion, however, land managers must balance the reestablishment of historical processes with their potential negative effects in sites with numerous at-risk species. This ecosystem was, and remains, part of a culturally modified landscape, where human activity has maintained unforested areas for millennia but now promotes mostly exotic flora. Although pre-European conditions cannot be fully restored, the historical data provided restoration insights unobtainable from current biological studies emphasizing the end point of long-term ecological change.Definición de Estrategias de Conservación con Perspectivas Históricas: un Estudio de Caso de un Ecosistema Degradado de Pastizal y Roble Resumen: La restauración de ecosistemas degradados puede estar limitada por la incertidumbre sobre las condiciones anteriores y la relevancia del pasado en cambios recientes. Puede ser difícil diferenciar entre hipótesis contrastantes sobre la función pasada del ecosistema, y los esfuerzos de restauración pueden enfatizar el restablecimiento de especies sin integración de los procesos ecológicos y culturales que una vez determinaron su ocurrencia. Como un estudio de caso, analizamos las descripciones históricas de un ecosistema de pastizal y roble en peligro en el suroeste de Columbia Británica, Canadá, para determinar las condiciones anteriores y evaluar su validez para definir objetos de restauración. Veintitrés documentos describieron este ecosistema de 1790 a 1951. La comparación de estos registros antiguos con la ocurrencia actual sugiere que >95% del hábita...

Are invasive species the drivers of ecological change?

“…Species invasion has been severe, with 144 naturalized exotic plant species (32% of the regional flora) representing 55-75% of local species richness and 80-90% of biomass [15,16]. The overwhelming impression is that native species have all but been displaced by invasive species, with the inference being that the invaders are competitively dominant over resident natives.…”

“…The overwhelming impression is that native species have all but been displaced by invasive species, with the inference being that the invaders are competitively dominant over resident natives. However, anthropogenic habitat alteration covaries strongly with invasion impacts [15,16], with only 1-5% of original habitat remaining and a history of long-term fire suppression [16]. Consequently, exotic dominance could have less to do with strong species interactions, such as competitive displacement, than with non-interactive processes, such as relative dispersal ability or altered disturbance regimes that are more limiting for native species than they are for invasive species [15,17,18].…”

Environmental change in Garry oak (Quercus garryana) ecosystems: the evolution of an eco-cultural landscape

“…Many researchers (Boyd 1986;Tveten and Fonda 1999), and accounts in historical journal materials (British Columbia Historical Society 1974;Dougan 1973;Duffus 2003;The Pioneer 1986) have concluded that aboriginal people used fire to manage food resources, most notably to increase yields of root vegetables (i.e., Camas), berries, seeds (Turner 1999), and forage species (Agee 1993;Turner 1999). Empirical evidence suggests that, on southeastern Vancouver Island and the Gulf Islands, this has been the case for millennia (MacDougall et al 2004). The aboriginal population in the Salish Sea region of BC (Fig.…”

“…These papers have highlighted pressing conservation issues such as landscape fragmentation, invasive species, herbivory, and the role of aboriginal land management using fire (MacDougall et al 2004;Gedalof et al 2006;Lea 2006;Pellatt et al 2007;Gonzales and Arcese 2008;Dunwiddie et al 2011;Bennett et al 2012). Unfortunately there seems to be a global disconnect between academic research and actual ecosystem restoration activities (Suding 2011).…”

Oak Regeneration Before and After Initial Restoration Efforts in a Tall Grass Oak Savanna Conference Paper

“…Finally, oak systems are culturally valued throughout the world (Hougner et al 2006, Fisher and Bliss 2008, Acacio et al 2010. As a result, Oregon white oaks are the subject of significant restoration and protection efforts throughout their range (Larsen and Morgan 1998, Fuchs 2001, MacDougall et al 2004. In Pierce and Thurston counties, Washington, oak stands are designated as critical areas and therefore receive special protection during the development process (Pierce County, Ord.…”