Defining clinical empathy: a grounded theory approach from the perspective of healthcare workers and patients in a multicultural setting

Abstract

ObjectiveTo define clinical empathy from the perspective of healthcare workers and patients from a multicultural setting.DesignGrounded theory approach using focus group discussions.SettingA health cluster in Singapore consisting of an acute hospital, a community hospital, ambulatory care teams, a medical school and a nursing school.Participants69 participants including doctors, nurses, medical students, nursing students, patients and allied health workers.Main outcome measuresA robust definition of clinical empathy.ResultsThe construct of clinical empathy is consistent across doctors, nurses, students, allied health and students. Medical empathy consists of an inner sense of empathy (imaginative, affective and cognitive), empathy behaviour (genuine concern and empathic communication) and a sense of connection (trust and rapport). This construct of clinical empathy is similar to definitions by neuroscientists but challenges a common definition of clinical empathy as a cognitive process with emotional detachment.ConclusionsThis paper has defined clinical empathy as ‘a sense of connection between the healthcare worker and the patient as a result of perspective taking arising from imaginative, affective and cognitive processes, which are expressed through behaviours and good communication skills that convey genuine concern’. A clear and multidimensional definition of clinical empathy will improve future education and research efforts in the application and impact of clinical empathy.

Proactive Personality and Innovative Work Behavior: Through the Juxtapose of Schumpeter's Theory of Innovation and Broaden-And-Build Theory

“…Outsiders may not experience such emotions, at least not to the same degree. Therefore, PIS translates into a sense of perceived acceptance by their supervisor and other insiders, expressing the vital “belonging” emotion (McMillan and Chavis, 1986 ; Tan et al, 2021 ).…”

Understanding of empathetic communication in acute hospital settings: a scoping review

“…This may be a result of empathy being traditionally defined by clinicians and from Western countries 61. There are linkages between the concept of empathy and culture,61 62 and articles about empathy research from a wide range of countries have been included in this review (despite articles in English only being included), which suggests that future research should consider cultural influences and differences when crafting a clear definition of both empathy and empathetic communication. We argue that culture is critically important in healthcare and future definitional work ought to be conducted in partnership with communities.…”

From Information Seeking to Social Support: Utilities of WhatsApp Group for Health Education and Postpartum Healing among CS Mothers in Nigeria

“…Communication and mental health experts unanimously agree that interpersonal empathic communication is a significant non-clinical therapy for psychological distress. Interpersonal empathic communication in this context refers to a dyadic interaction whereby one uses communication skills such as active listening, guided expressions (language competence) as well as bonding and connection to draw one‖s attachment to a psychologically-distressed individual (Tan et al, 2021;Li, 2021). Studies show that empathic communication influences the recovery pace and health outcome of individuals in a state of psychological distress (Moudatsou, Stavropoulou, Philalithis & Koukouli, 2020) such as postpartum depression.…”

“…Women in this condition cope differently, using workable strategies such as religious, emotion-based, and self-denying strategies (Gutiérrez-Zotes et al, 2016;Azale, Fekadu, Medhin & Hanlon, 2018), interpersonal communication with others, selfsocial support and positive thinking (Tang, Zhang & Zhu, 2020). Empathic communication a form of emotional support that includes active listening, bonding, and self-feelings from people around is equally an essential coping mechanism woman with PPD adopt (Dennis, 2003;Friedman & Resnick, 2009;Tan et al, 2021).…”