Dealing with foreign cultural paradigms: A systematic review on intercultural challenges of international medical graduates

Abstract

ObjectivesAn increasing number of International Medical Graduates (IMG), who are defined to be physicians working in a country other than their country of origin and training, immigrate to Western countries. In order to ensure safe and high-quality patient care, they have to take medical and language tests. This systematic review aims to (1) collect all empiric research on intercultural communication of IMGs in medical settings, (2) identify and categorize all text passages mentioning intercultural issues in the included studies, and (3) describe the most commonly reported intercultural areas of communication of IMGs.MethodsThis review was based on the PRISMA-Guidelines for systematic reviews. We conducted a broad and systematic electronic literature search for empiric research in the following databases: MEDLINE, BIOSIS Citation Index, BIOSIS Previews, KCI-Korean Journal Database and SciELO Citation Index. The search results were synthesized and analyzed with the aid of coding systems. These coding systems were based on textual analysis and derived from the themes and topics of the results and discussion sections from the included studies. A quality assessment was performed, comparing the studies with their corresponding checklist (COREQ or STROBE). Textual results of the studies were extracted and categorized.ResultsAmong 10,630 search results, 47 studies were identified for analysis. 31 studies were qualitative, 12 quantitative and 4 studies used mixed methods. The quality assessment revealed a low level of quality of the studies in general. The following intercultural problems were identified: IMGs were not familiar with shared decision-making and lower hierarchies in the health care system in general. They had difficulties with patient-centered care, the subtleties of the foreign language and with the organizational structures of the new health care system. In addition, they described the medical education in their home countries as science-oriented, without focusing on psychosocial aspects.ConclusionThere is a need for a better training of IMGs on culture-related and not culture-related topics in the new workplace country. The topics that emerged in this review constitute a basis for developing these courses. Further empiric research is needed to describe the findings of this review more precisely and should be in accordance with the existing reporting guidelines.

Assessment of knowledge and attitudes towards safety events reporting among residents in a community health system

“…It was also felt that many of the residents came from a culture with a more defined hierarchy and either fear of reporting superiors or feeling that this showed a lack of respect was a possible contributing factor. On literature review, this is in line with a recent systematic review of 47 studies which concluded that IMG’s faced difficulties with a loss of status and less defined hierarchies with respect to their patients, staff and supervisors as compared to home countries [14]. As far as we are aware, no studies had looked at the cultural background of residents with respect to safety event reporting.…”

Physician-related determinants of medical end-of-life decisions – A mortality follow-back study in Switzerland

“…International medical graduates made substantially fewer MELDs than those who graduated from a Swiss university and when they made an MELD, they less often reported shared decision-making with the patient and/or their relatives. International medical graduates may be less familiar with shared decision-making and patient-centered care [ 25 ]. At the time of the survey, 29% of all physicians in Switzerland were international graduates, with almost 60% of them originating from Germany [ 26 , 27 ].…”

International: Overseas doctors of the NHS: migration, transition, challenges and towards resolution

“…21,37,38 Sharing clinical information with a patient and family and taking consent may vary between countries and cultures, shaped by laws and need to be addressed early in a doctor's career. 39 Working effectively within teams, now an almost universal practice, is more complex than it at first appears. Decisions are best made when all necessary information is available, which in turn is possible only when the consultant invites even the most junior members to contribute.…”