Dating Muslim Traditions: A Survey

Motzki, Harald

doi:10.1163/1570058053640349

Cited by 43 publications

(13 citation statements)

References 0 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Analisis matan dapat memberi kontribusi dalam menetapkan masa kemunculan hadis dengan baik apabila ia dikombinasikan dengan metode-metode lainnya. 35 Motzki menegaskan bahwa prinsip dan premis metode ini tidak cukup teliti (not sufficiently sophisticated) sehingga menimbulkan keraguan mengenai tingkat validitas prinsipprinsip dan premis-premis pada metode tersebut. Secara umum muncul kebimbangan, apa mungkin menetapkan kemunculan suatu hadis secara presisi hanya berdasarkan pada analisis matan saja.…”

Section: Analisis Kritis Terhadap Metode R Marston Speightunclassified

Form Analysis Sebagai Metode Kritik Matan: Menakar Keakuratan Pemikiran Robert Marston Speight (1924-2011)

Muna

2021

ALQUDS

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Together with sanad, matn is the main component in a hadith. Among the important discussions regarding matn is the existence of several matn which have different editorials while informing one incident. This problem is usually called the problem of matn with various versions (ta'addud al-riwāyāt; variant version). In the West, this problem has received the attention of many academics, among them Robert Marston Speight. He offers a form analysis method for studying and researching the problem of matn with various versions. This paper systematically describes how the Speight analysis method is, and how its position is in the study of hadith in the West. Critical analysis of the Speight method was also carried out by comparing it with the views of other academics and also the views of muhaddiṡūn. This paper uses a qualitative method in the form of a research library with a critical analysis model. This paper shows several conclusions: the method of analysis used by Speight, namely form analysis, is the development of the method of analysis of the matn which has been introduced, especially by Schacht with the purposes of dating tradition; many academics both in the West and the East doubted Speight's method of analysis and criticized its accuracy; and when compared to the muhaddiṡūn method, the Speight method contains several methodological flaws.

show abstract

Section: Analisis Kritis Terhadap Metode R Marston Speightunclassified

Form Analysis Sebagai Metode Kritik Matan: Menakar Keakuratan Pemikiran Robert Marston Speight (1924-2011)

Muna

2021

ALQUDS

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Suatu sumber dianggap terpercaya, apabila mampu menjawab dengan pasti dua pertanyaan, berapa jauh jarak waktu sumber dengan peristiwa yang dilaporkan dan apakah sumber tersebut memberikan informasi dengan tepat. (Motzki H. , 2005;205) Ahli hadis muslim sejak awal telah merumuskan suatu teori tentang otentisitas hadis untuk menunjukkan hadis yang otentik maupun yang palsu. Hadis dikatakan otentik melalui proses penyeleksian dua unsur pokok hadis, yaitu şahīh sanad dan şahīh matan.…”

Section: A Pendahuluanunclassified

“…Kronologi relatif dari teks terutama didasarkan pada aspek konten, dan representasi dari perkembangan hukum Islam dibangun di atasnya, tidak mengarah pada kesimpulan yang pasti. (Motzki H. , 2005: xiii)…”

Section: Implikasi Teori Common Link Terhadap Kesejarahan Hadisunclassified

Kesejarahan Hadis dalam Tinjauan Teori Common Link

Suwarno

2018

Hadith.J.Living Hadis

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This study entitled Kesejarahan Hadis Tinjauan Teori Common Link. The background of the study is study of authenticity, origin, and history of hadith has become an interesting topic and even a debate from the beginning of Islam until now. Interesting and a debate because it concerns the authenticity of Islamic teachings. Among the new theories and worldviews in contemporary criticism of contemporary hadith are the common link theory. For it is formulated the purpose of this study is to find out how to work and understand the implications of the theory of common links to the historic Hadith of the Prophet. The results of this study indicate that the common link theory impacts on the source or origin of hadith based on whom. Differences in interpreting common links determine which hadith comes from whom. Penelitian ini berjudul "Kesejarahan Hadis Hadiah Teori Common Link". Latar belakang penelitian untuk mengetahui keaslian, asal, dan sejarah hadis telah menjadi topik yang menarik dan bahkan menjadi perdebatan sejak awal Islam hingga sekarang. Menarik dan menjadi perdebatan karena menyangkut keaslian ajaran Islam. Di antara teori-teori baru dan pandangan dunia dalam kritik kontemporer hadis adalah teori common link. Oleh karena itu dirumuskan tujuan dari penelitian ini adalah untuk mengetahui bagaimana cara kerja dan memahami implikasi dari teori common link dengan historisitas hadis Nabi. Hasil penelitian ini menunjukkan bahwa teori common link berdampak pada sumber atau asal-usul hadis yang didasarkan pada siapa (rawi atau nabi). Perbedaan dalam menafsirkan common link menentukan sebuah hadis berasal dari siapa.

show abstract

“…6 6 For an overview of the hadith debate, see Motzki (2005). Another pertinent debate concerns the original form of texts conventionally dated to the formative period such as Malik’s Muwatta’ and the Musannaf of ‘Abd al‐Razzaq; for evidence that such works originated as lecture notes, and did not achieve fixed form until later, see Schoeler (2004).…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

‘A’isha bint Abi Bakr and her Contributions to the Formation of the Islamic Tradition

Geissinger

2011

Religion Compass

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

A'isha bint Abi Bakr (d. 678 CE) is probably best known today as a wife of the Prophet Muhammad, whose life is particularly notable due to her involvement in several dramatic events which subsequently loomed large in inter-Muslim sectarian polemic. However, her portrayal in many Sunni medieval texts from a variety of literary genres as an authority on subjects ranging from law to variant readings of the Quran is beginning to receive more scholarly attention. This article brings together existing critical research on the presentation of 'A'isha in classical Muslim works as a source of legal traditions and hadiths as well as a transmitter of the Quran, summarizes some of my own research, and points to ways that her image as an intellectual figure continues to be important to many Muslims today.

show abstract

Dating Muslim Traditions: A Survey

Cited by 43 publications

References 0 publications

Form Analysis Sebagai Metode Kritik Matan: Menakar Keakuratan Pemikiran Robert Marston Speight (1924-2011)

Form Analysis Sebagai Metode Kritik Matan: Menakar Keakuratan Pemikiran Robert Marston Speight (1924-2011)

Kesejarahan Hadis dalam Tinjauan Teori Common Link

‘A’isha bint Abi Bakr and her Contributions to the Formation of the Islamic Tradition

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About