“…First, regarding the musical expectancy mechanism, some investigations have found that violations of musical expectancies correlate with physiological and experienced changes in arousal, but not of valence (Egermann et al, 2013;Koelsch et al, 2008;Steinbeis et al, 2006), whereas others have found changes in pleasantness and liking ratings (Cheung et al, 2019;Shany et al, 2019). Second, regarding the evidence for the effects of rhythmic entrainment on valence, the evidence is contradictory: some studies have found significant effects (Bernardi et al, 2017(Bernardi et al, , 2018Labbé & Grandjean, 2014;Witek et al, 2014) while others have found no association (Janata et al, 2012). And third, regarding the effects of music on experienced tension, perhaps the most informative evidence has been provided by Illie and Thompson (2006) who compared the effects of musical loudness, tempo, and pitch height (and their equivalents in vocalizations) on the participants' valence, and tense and energetic arousal (Schimmack & Grob, 2000).…”