Cyclic fluctuations in hospital bed occupancy in Roma (Italy): supply or demand driven?

Abstract

The objective of this study was to assess hospital bed occupancy both by planned and unplanned cases, and to assess how supply and demand affect bed occupancy. Data was obtained from the Lazio Hospital Information System (HIS) dataset on all hospital discharges from July 1998 to June 2001. Using Diagnosis Related Groups (DRG) as the reason for hospital stay, admissions were classified into four categories: 'planned stay', 'presumed planned stay', 'presumed unplanned stay', and 'unplanned stay'. Time series analysis of daily bed occupancy by category of stay was performed. Generalized Additive Models (GAMs) were used to asses the effect of weekdays and holidays on bed occupancy. Fluctuations in daily occupancy were observed in all categories of stay-in general, bed occupancy decreased over weekends, on national holidays, and during the major holiday season of August. In comparison with unplanned stays, the largest fluctuations were observed for planned stays while presumed planned and unplanned stays showed lesser fluctuations. It is possible to distinguish planned and unplanned hospital stays by using DRG grouping. Cyclic rigidities in the supply of services rather than the availability of beds or demand for beds seem to dictate hospital use in Roma so that restrictions in services hamper any reallocation of beds for 'planned stay' when demand for 'unplanned stay' beds declines.

OR and the challenge to improve the NHS: modelling for insight and improvement in in-patient flows

“…The National Audit Office (2000) noted a big difference between hospitals in the proportion of electives brought in early, suggesting some of these may be unnecessary. Greater variation in planned than unplanned work is also a feature of other health systems, for example in Italy (Fusco et al, 2003). Figure 4 shows the considerable impact of variation in discharge activity across the week; the dips are weekends, and small peaks of activity either side of these can be seen.…”

Managing capacity and demand across the patient journey

“…7 However, some believe that bed shortages are self-inflicted and compounded by the known, predictable system dynamics that create additional problems for bed availability. 6,8 The daily bed cycle…”

Influenza outbreaks and hospital bed occupancy in Rome (Italy): current management does not accommodate for seasonal variations in demand

“…GAMs have been repeatedly used to study the time course of different health phenomena; 16,26,28,29 we used GAMs in analysing trends of programmable hospital admissions 27 and found them a powerful tool to adjust for short-and long-term variability and to study the possible interaction between time and other variables. In this study, GAM estimates of influenza-related occupancy are adjusted by daily variations for week days, and by seasonal variations, and they are affected by the summer decrease in hospital occupancy.…”