Culturally Universal or Culturally Specific: A Comparative Study of Anticipated Female Leadership Styles in Taiwan and the United States

Abstract

Guided by Bass and Avolio's leadership frameworks and Hofstede's modified cultural dimensions, the present cross-cultural study aims to compare and explore the relationships between cultural values and anticipated female leadership styles in nonprofit organizations in Taiwan and the United States. Regression and t-test analyses of 307 participants in 138 Rotary Clubs in the two societies reveal two research findings. First, Rotary Club members in Taiwan have higher scores in all the cultural dimensions of collectivism, masculinity, and lifelong relationships than their U.S. counterparts. Second, transformational leadership proves to be the most anticipated leadership style among Rotary Club members in both cultures. The research findings indicate that culture alone cannot account for the anticipated female leadership styles. Therefore, a combination of Bass's culturally universal approach and Hofstede's culturally specific approach is proposed to tackle more variables in future female leadership studies.

The effects of national cultures on two technologically advanced countries: The case of e‐leadership in South Korea and the United States

“…Research has shown that national culture impacts leadership (Chao & Tian, 2011; Dorfman & House, 2004; House et al. 2004).…”

Twenty‐first century leadership: international imperatives

“…First, compassionate consideration for the well‐being of employees, society and the environment needs to underpin intelligent stewardship of organisational and national resources in complex, pressured and ambiguous settings (Li et al , 2011; Useem et al , 2005). Such stewardship should also encourage by‐partisan solutions to socioeconomic issues (especially of vulnerable population groups) based on ethical collaborative partnerships (Maria and Arenas, 2009), and the building of trust to accomplish shared vision and goals (Chao and Tian, 2011). Managers should aspire to intelligent stewardship as a relevant, long‐term objective, especially as, in general, short‐term political decisions often underpin the way business is performed and managed.…”

Educational Leadership in the U.S. and Vietnam: A Cross-Culture Comparative Study

“…Particularly, studies into non-Western societies will benefit academic communities as well as policymakers and practitioners with different perspectives on school leadership (Vogel, 2015; Chen et al, 2016;Tang et al, 2011;Chao & Tian, 2011). Given the rise of new non-Western players in the global economy, comparative studies will provide potential answers as to why some countries may do better than others in education.…”

“…Most scholars agree that education is among the most important independent variables in the functioning of a competitive economy. Producing "knowledge workers" is, therefore, one of the main challenges that many countries face (Walker & Dimmock, 2002).Particularly, studies into non-Western societies will benefit academic communities as well as policymakers and practitioners with different perspectives on school leadership (Vogel, 2015; Chen et al, 2016;Tang et al, 2011;Chao & Tian, 2011). Given the rise of new non-Western players in the global economy, comparative studies will provide potential answers as to why some countries may do better than others in education.…”