Country-level determinants and consequences of overconfidence in the ambitious entrepreneurship segment

Abstract

Countries vary widely and systematically in the extent to which the ambitions of their entrepreneurs differ from their realisations. We label this discrepancy entrepreneurial overconfidence (EOC). Although a certain level of EOC may be beneficial for an economy, we provide empirical support for the argument that if entrepreneurial ambitions substantially and systematically exceed realisations, this may be at the cost of economic and societal prosperity. Therefore, we need to know more about country levels of EOC and their determinants, particularly with respect to the growth-oriented segment of entrepreneurship. Combining data on entrepreneurial ambitions from Global Entrepreneurship Monitor and data on realisations from Eurostat, we construct a measure of EOC at the country level and correlate its variation across 23 European Union (EU) countries over the period 2004–2015 with a set of economic and cultural factors. Among other findings, our results show that ambitions exceed realisations in almost all countries, but that this discrepancy is significantly greater for new member countries entering the EU since 2004. Policy implications of our results are discussed, particularly for promoting ambitious entrepreneurship in countries at the intermediate development stage.

From Entrepreneurial Intentions to Entrepreneurial Behavior

“…This is consistent with the analysis of overoptimism (cf. Brieger, Bäro, Criaco, & Terjesen, 2020;Cieślik, Kaciak, & van Stel, 2018), in which young people see more favorable conditions for seizing available opportunities in the market. Contrary to this result, entrepreneurial behavior among students seems to be very low.…”

How Do Failed Entrepreneurs Cope with Their Prior Failure When They Seek Subsequent Re-Entry into Serial Entrepreneurship? Failed Entrepreneurs’ Optimism and Defensive Pessimism and Coping Humor as a Moderator

“…Optimism facilitates prompt decision-making while starting new ventures, as well as the drive to obtain the relevant skills and experiences [ 86 ]; the career ambitions of entrepreneurs may inculcate optimism in order to pursue career advancements. Smith et al [ 87 ] found, with regards to an optimistic perspective, that resilience and the negation of women’s glass ceiling beliefs (which could diminish their career ambition) are positively associated with work engagement.…”

The performance of private companies in China before and during the global financial crisis: firms’ characteristics and entrepreneurs’ attributes

“…Accordingly, we build two categorical variables ( Perceived social status and Perceived economic status ) on the basis of the answers given by the respondents in rating their economic and social status on a 10-point Likert scale; they vary from 1 (highest relative position) to 10 (lowest relative position). 18 It is worth noticing that although the CPES does not allow us to build measures of self-efficacy (Bandura 1997;Poon et al 2006) or overoptimism (Cieslik et al 2018), the subjective evaluation of the entrepreneurs' status is highly informative. For instance, as suggested by Koryak et al (2015), perceived social status may act as a proxy for a measure of self-esteem.…”