“…Electron spin resonance (ESR) studies on tooth enamel (Blackwell, 1994;Curnoe et al, 2001) have produced a preposterously broad range of datesd4.38e 0.36 Madfor the three fossiliferous members. Substantially more reasonable age ranges of about 2.0e1.6 Ma for Member 1, 1.5e1.0 Ma for Member 2, and approximately 1.0e0.8 Ma for Member 3 are indicated by palaeontological correlation (Brain, 1993b;McKee et al, 1995;Vrba, 1995), UePb studies of bovid tooth enamel (Balter et al, 2008) and speleothems (R. Pickering et al, 2011), and analysis of buried cosmogenic nuclides (Gibbon et al, 2014).…”