Coping and compromise: a qualitative study of how primary health care providers respond to health reform in China

Abstract

BackgroundHealth reform in China since 2009 has emphasized basic public health services to enhance the function of Community Health Services as a primary health care facility. A variety of studies have documented these efforts, and the challenges these have faced, yet up to now the experience of primary health care (PHC) providers in terms of how they have coped with these changes remains underdeveloped. Despite the abundant literature on psychological coping processes and mechanisms, the application of coping research within the context of human resources for health remains yet to be explored. This research aims to understand how PHC providers coped with the new primary health care model and the job characteristics brought about by these changes.MethodsSemi-structured interviews with primary health care workers were conducted in Jinan city of Shandong province in China. A maximum variation sampling method selected 30 PHC providers from different specialties. Thematic analysis was used drawing on a synthesis of theories related to the Job Demands-Resources model, work adjustment, and the model of exit, voice, loyalty and neglect to understand PHC providers’ coping strategies.ResultsOur interviews identified that the new model of primary health care significantly affected the nature of primary health work and triggered a range of PHC providers’ coping processes. The results found that health workers perceived their job as less intensive than hospital medical work but often more trivial, characterized by heavy workload, blurred job description, unsatisfactory income, and a lack of professional development. However, close relationship with community and low work pressure were satisfactory. PHC providers’ processing of job demands and resources displayed two ways of interaction: aggravation and alleviation. Processing of job demands and resources led to three coping strategies: exit, passive loyalty, and compromise with new roles and functions.ConclusionsPrimary health care providers employed coping strategies of exit, passive loyalty, and compromise to deal with changes in primary health work. In light of these findings, our paper concludes that it is necessary for the policymakers to provide further job resources for CHS, and involve health workers in policy-making. The introduction of particular professional training opportunities to support job role orientation for PHC providers is advocated.

Motivating factors on performance of primary care workers in China: a systematic review and meta-analysis

“…As for the risk of bias, more than half of the included studies presented a low risk of bias, with the total score ranging from 6 points to 10 points (in online supplementary appendix 3). Included studies analysed the motivation of PCWs from different perspectives: some measured job satisfaction15–30; some explored the motivating factors’ influence on attrition and retention18 22 31–35; some studied the impact of some policies or interventions on the motivating factors for health workers 31 36–46…”

‘I have no love for such people, because they leave us to suffer’: a qualitative study of health workers’ responses and institutional adaptations to absenteeism in rural Uganda

“…Finally, this was not an exhaustive evaluation of all coping pathways,44 45 but rather one which relied on a stress-coping model41 that has been widely validated in the health sector 17 42 43 55…”

“…The Lazarus and Folkman41 stress–coping framework was used. This framework has been widely validated with concordance of findings in studies on job performance of tertiary hospital nurses,42 responses to health reforms by primary healthcare providers43 and conceptual adaptations in bereavement research,44 but not without mixed results 45. Lazarus’ framework presupposes that coping responses are triggered when an individual experiences a stressor which exceeds their abilities, skills and resources to control its effects 41.…”

Family medicine training in China: crisis and opportunity

“…The attempt to retrain large number of primary care providers into family physician has met numerous problems; level of education varies among providers at primary care level9; low motivation for retraining10 due to insufficient support from the system 11. Low level of education, low financial support and high demand from the system12 drive primary care providers to migrate into better pays leaving their posts in rural communities13 or leave them with low morale and motivation 14. Subsequently, tertiary care medical centres in cities continue to be packed with patients with primary care needs 15.…”