A template‐free approach based on the use of eutectic mixtures composed of 2‐hydroxymethylthiophene and furfuryl alcohol has been designed for the preparation of hierarchical sulfur‐doped carbons (SPCs) in monolithic form. The temperature used for carbonization, for example, 600, 800, or 900 °C, determined most of the physicochemical properties of the resulting SPCs. Thus, the surface area increased from below 400 to up 775 m2 g−1, along with the carbonization temperature, whereas the sulfur content decreased from approximately 15 to 5 wt %. The oxygen reduction reaction performance in samples carbonized at 900 °C was good, with the four‐electron‐transfer reaction prevailing over the two‐electron‐transfer one. Interestingly, the methanol tolerance and stability of these SPCs were also remarkable, with less than 5 % current decrease immediately after methanol addition, whereas, in terms of stability, the current decrease was below 8 % after 20000 s. This performance was in the range of that found not only for other SPCs, but also for many nitrogen‐doped and even some dual‐doped (S and N) ones.