Consulted ethical problems of clinical nursing practice: perspective of faculty members in Japan

Abstract

BackgroundThere are several studies that have targeted student nurses, but few have clarified the details pertaining to the specific ethical problems in clinical practice with the viewpoint of the nursing faculty. This study was to investigate the ethical problems in clinical practice reported by student nurses to Japanese nursing faculty members for the purpose of improving ethics education in clinical practice.MethodThe subjects comprised 705 nursing faculty members (we sent three questionnaires to one university) who managed clinical practice education at 235 Japanese nursing universities. We performed a simple tabulation of the four items shown in the study design. 1) the details of student nurse consultations regarding ethics in clinical practice (involving the students themselves, nurses, care workers, clinical instructors, and nursing faculty members); 2) the methods of ethics education in clinical practice; 3) the difficulties experienced by the nursing faculty members who received the consultations; and 4) the relationship between clinical practice and lectures on ethics. Furthermore, the analysis was based on the idea of ethical principles, respect for persons, beneficence, and justice.ResultsThe response rate was 28% (198 questionnaires). The nursing faculty members were consulted for various problems by student nurses. The details of these consultations were characterized by the principles of respect for patient by nurses, the principles of benevolence by faculty and clinical instructors, and the principle of justice pertaining to evaluations. The results indicate that there is an awareness among the nursing faculty regarding the necessity of some sort of ethics education at clinical settings. Moreover, based on the nature of the contents of the consultations regarding the hospital and staff, it was evident that the nursing faculty struggled in providing responses. More than half of subjects exhibited an awareness of the relationship between the classroom lectures on ethics and clinical practice.ConclusionThe results suggest the need for analyzing the ethical viewpoints of student nurses, prior learning, and collaboration with related courses as part of ethics education in clinical practice.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12912-017-0217-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Nursing Students' Experienced Ethical Problems in Clinical Practicum and Clinical Self-Regulated Learning Levels:A Cross-Sectional Study

“…Such experiences cause a decrease in motivation among students. 20 The teacher-student relationship is a power relationship based on students' dependence on teachers' professional knowledge, skills, and authority by its nature. Clinical educators and health professionals are required to adopt a respectful attitude so that they can influence students both professionally and personally, and increase students' motivation to learn.…”

Explaining the Status of Clinical Nursing Education: A Qualitative Research in Iran

“…Similar to our study, other studies revealed that the implementation of educational plans is not in a way that fosters creative and critical thinking in students, so they are not able to apply their knowledge in clinical situations. Besides, there is no appropriate psychological support from instructors in clinical settings (3,(17)(18)(19).…”

Educational challenges in teaching nursing ethics: Perspectives of educators in Japan

“…It was assumed that students should be provided with an opportunity to associate classroom learning with what occurred in practical training. [40] To improve this situation, it seemed to be effective for nursing ethics educators to cooperate with teachers in charge of practical training to examine what and how students should learn in classes. However educators have not fully discussed improving ethical skills of nursing students through nursing education.…”