“…long known to be associated with grave disease." Familial clubbing, however, without clinical significance, in which the inheritance is of Mendelian dominant type, is well recognized (Horsfall, 1936;Seaton, 1938;Mendlowitz, 1942;Davis, 1946), although Witherspoon (1936) found only 14 families reported in the literature. Mendlowitz gave an exhaustive list of conditions associated with clubbing, at the same time pertinently remarking that " mere coincidence in isolated cases is not sufficient evidence of a causal relationship."…”