Comparison of three solar water heaters technologies through a full-scale experimental station

Abstract

The aim of the solar water heater designed for Tahala grid project, is to provide renewable energy to the residents of Tahala village in southern of Morocco, our contribution as LERED* laboratory to this project consists of the creation of a novel solar water heater, with a long lifetime, high efficiency, reliability and quality, that uses solar concentration instead of direct exposition in the hope of reaching high temperatures even during cold weather and the winter season. In order to evaluate the performances of this new solar water heater, it was necessary to build a full-scale solar water heater test bench station, which allows to monitor the thermal station remotely, in order to start new experiments, measure various parameters such as cumulated thermal energy, the maximum reached temperature, efficiency, and so on, in order to compare the performances of each solar water heating technology in various weather conditions. In this study, we choose to test and compare three solar water heater technologies: water-in-glass evacuated tube collectors, selective surface flat-plate collectors, and the novel design that consists of a Fresnel mirrors concentrator with a water-in-glass evacuated tube collector with a dual sun tracking system. The result of experiments shows that under normal weather conditions, the Fresnel mirrors concentrator efficiency reached 48%, followed by the evacuated tube collector that have an efficiency of 42.3 %, and then come at the last position the flat-plate collector with an efficiency 36.3%.

A Comparative Study of Solar Heater Technologies for Domestic Water Heating

“…appropriate for this secondary study [42]. The study goals are met via a design that does not include any modification or intervention, namely the collection and analysis of existing literature on the efficiency, economic feasibility, and environmental effects of different solar water heater technologies [43].…”