Comparison of ICD-9 Codes for Depression and Alcohol Misuse to Survey Instruments Suggests These Codes Should Be Used with Caution

Abstract

Background Research suggests depression and alcohol misuse are highly prevalent among chronic hepatitis C (CHC) patients, which is of clinical concern. Aims To compare ICD-9 codes for depression and alcohol misuse to validated survey instruments. Methods Among CHC patients, we assessed how well electronic ICD-9 codes for depression and alcohol misuse predicted these disorders using validated instruments. Results Of 4,874 patients surveyed, 56% were male and 52% had a history of injection drug use. Based on the PHQ-8, the prevalence of depression was 30% compared to 14% based on ICD-9 codes within 12 months of survey, 37% from ICD-9 codes any time before or within 12 months after survey, and 48% from ICD-9 codes any time before or within 24 months after survey. ICD-9 codes predicting PHQ-8 depression had a sensitivity ranging from 59–88% and a specificity ranging from 33–65%. Based on the AUDIT-C, the prevalence of alcohol misuse was 21% compared to 3–23% using ICD-9 codes. The sensitivity of ICD9 codes to predict AUDIT-C score ranged from 9–35% and specificity from 80–98%. Overall 39% of patients reported ever binge drinking; with a sensitivity of ICD-9s to predict binge drinking ranging from 7–33% and a specificity from 84–98%. More than half of patients had either an ICD-9 code for depression, a survey score indicating depression, or both (59%); more than one-third had the same patterns for alcohol misuse (36%). Conclusions ICD-9 codes were limited in predicting current depression and alcohol misuse, suggesting that caution should be exercised when using ICD-9 codes to assess depression or alcohol misuse among CHC patient.

Mental health status in veterans residing in rural versus non-rural areas: results from the veterans’ health study

“…Alcohol misuse was assessed using the AUDIT-C instrument, a widely used and validated scale often used in population health studies [ 54 ]. The AUDIT-C has been found to be a good measure of alcohol misuse [ 55 , 56 ].…”

Trends in Psychiatric Hospitalization of Children and Adolescents in Spain between 2005 and 2015

“…Patients with a primary diagnosis were selected upon discharge from abuse or dependence on psychoactive substances. Main diagnoses for hospital discharges according to selection of ICD-9-MC codes were used in previous research [21,22]. Codes used are detailed in Table 1.…”

Longitudinal Drinking Patterns and Their Clinical Correlates in Million Veteran Program Participants

“…This is particularly apparent for the group characterized as having potentially hazardous/harmful alcohol use, where only 26% had a clinical diagnosis of AUD. Boscarino and colleagues () also found a modest correlation between ICD‐9 codes and positive AUDIT‐C screening in their study of chronic HCV patients. Therefore, using both AUD and AUDIT‐C trajectories may provide greater information than either alone, a finding that is consistent with that reported by Justice and colleagues () using a genetic criterion measure.…”