Comparison of Effects of Local Anesthesia and Two-Point Acupressure on the Severity of Venipuncture Pain Among Hospitalized 6–12-Year-Old Children

Abstract

The aim of the present study was to compare the effects of topical anesthesia and acupressure at the Yintang (Extra 1) and the Laogong (P-8) points on the severity of venipuncture pain among hospitalized 6-12-year-old children. A sample (n = 120) of 6-12-year-old hospitalized children was recruited from two teaching hospitals located in Rafsanjan, Iran. The children were allocated to the topical anesthesia, acupressure, and control groups. For children in the topical anesthesia and the acupressure groups, eutectic mixture of local anesthetic (EMLA) cream and two-point acupressure were used, respectively, prior to performing venipuncture, whereas children in the control group only received routine prevenipuncture care. The severity of venipuncture pain was evaluated 5 minutes after performing venipuncture by using the Face, Leg, Activity, Cry, and Consolability behavioral pain assessment scale. The findings revealed that pain severity in both experimental groups was significantly lower than that in the control group, whereas there was no significant difference between the experimental groups regarding pain severity. Although acupressure was as effective as topical anesthesia cream in alleviating children's venipuncture pain, nurses are recommending to use acupressure instead of pharmacological pain management agents because of its greater safety, cost-effectiveness, and applicability.

The Effect of a Hand Massage on the Physiological Changes Induced by Intravenous Line Insertion in Children Aged Three to Six: A Clinical Trial

“…In this study, the effects of massage therapy on changes in the physiological parameters induced by intravenous line insertion (including increased respiratory rate, heart rate, and blood pressure, and decreased arterial blood saturation) were investigated in children aged three to six years. The results indicated that the respiratory rate and heart rate of children in both experimental and control groups were significantly higher after IV insertion than before this administration, which is consistent with previous reports (6,7,22,23).…”

“…One of the most painful experiences that a child has when admitted to the hospital is inserting the needle into the vein (7,8). For this reason, some researchers have recently focused on studying possible methods of managing and reducing the physiological effects of needle insertion in children (9).…”

Acupuncture for pediatric pain: The trend of evidence-based research

“… 14 Pour et al., 2017 6–12 year old 120 Venipuncture pain Three-arm RCT Acupressure at the Extra −1 (Yintang) and the PC8 (Laogong) was as effective as topical anesthesia cream in alleviating children's venipuncture pain. 15 …”

“…This report evaluates research in pediatric acupuncture and pain management, in which approximately 55% of the selected articles were related to procedural pediatric pain management. The pediatric procedures included infant heel lancing, 3 , 4 , 7 , 8 , 9 ,nsillectomy 10 , 11 and dental-related, 12 myringotomy tube surgery, 13 kidney biopsy, 14 ventipuncture, 15 and endoscopic pre-procedural anxiety. 16 Collectively, these studies researched how acupuncture could lead to the reduction of post-operative pain, emergence irritation, procedural time, and infantile crying.…”

The Atraumatic Care Approach in Pediatric Nursing: Non-Pharmacological Applications in Reducing Pain, Stress, and Anxiety

“…(72,73) Çocuğun ağrısını azaltmaya yönelik kullanılan farmakolojik olmayan yöntemlerle ilgili yapılan bazı araştırma sonuçları Tablo 1'de gösterildi. (19,25,26,39,40,(44)(45)(46)(47)(48)(49)(50)52,(54)(55)(56)(57)(58)(61)(62)(63)(64)(65)(66)(67)(68)(69)(70) Çocuğun anksiyetesini azaltma: Anksiyete, çocuğun hastaneye yatmaya, hastalığa ya da tıbbi işlemlere uyum sağlamasını olumsuz olarak etkiler. (3)(4)(5)7,74) Tıbbi işlemler öncesi stres yaşayan çocuklar sonraki uygulamalarda daha yoğun anksiyete yaşayabilir.…”