Comparative support for the niche variation hypothesis that more generalized populations also are more heterogeneous

Abstract

There is extensive evidence that some species of ecological generalists, which use a wide diversity of resources, are in fact heterogeneous collections of relatively specialized individuals. This within-population variation, or ''individual specialization,'' is a key requirement for frequency-dependent interactions that may drive a variety of types of evolutionary diversification and may influence the population dynamics and ecological interactions of species. Consequently, it is important to understand when individual specialization is likely to be strong or weak. The niche variation hypothesis (NVH) suggests that populations tend to become more generalized when they are released from interspecific competition. This niche expansion was proposed to arise via increased variation among individuals rather than increased individual niche breadth. Consequently, we expect ecological generalists to exhibit stronger individual specialization, but this correlation has been repeatedly rejected by empiricists. The drawback with previous empirical tests of the NVH is that they use morphological variation as a proxy for niche variation, ignoring the role of behavior and complex phenotype-function relationships. Here, we used diet data to directly estimate niche variation among individuals. Consistent with the NVH, we show that more generalized populations also exhibit more niche variation. This trend is quite general, appearing in all five case studies examined: three-spine stickleback, Eurasian perch, Anolis lizards, intertidal gastropods, and a community of neotropical frogs. Our results suggest that generalist populations may tend to be more ecologically variable. Whether this translates into greater genetic variation, evolvability, or ecological stability remains to be determined. frequency dependence ͉ individual specialization ͉ niche expansion

Prey choice and habitat use drive sea otter pathogen exposure in a resource-limited coastal system

“…When combined with health and disease indices, these longitudinal studies can elucidate the disease outcomes related to individual behavioral strategies, an approach well established in human epidemiology. Given the growing recognition of individual behavioral specialization strategies in many taxa (29), the methods used here have broad potential utility for better understanding the causes and consequences of disease in wildlife populations.…”

Biofilm responses to marine fish farm wastes

“…Eliminado: mentioned Niche variation in the biofilm community was assessed using stable isotopes under a similar conceptual basis as Bolnick et al (, 2007) . We used six community-level metrics described by Layman et al (, 2007), briefly: 1) δ 13 C range (CR), which indicates the quantity of basal resources and niche diversification at the base of the food web, 2) δ 15 N range (NR), which shows the degree of trophic diversity, 3) total area (TA), which reflects the amount of niche space occupied by a community, 4) mean distance to centroid (CD), which shows the overall degree of trophic diversity, and is specially useful in cases with outlier species, 5) mean nearest neighbour distance (NND), which is a proxy of trophic redundancy and 6) standard deviation of the nearest neighbour distance (SDNND), which indicates the evenness of the distribution of trophic niches in a community.…”

Ecomorphology and use of food resources: inter- and intraspecific relationships of fish fauna associated with macrophyte stands

“…If so, do species with higher morphological diversity (e.g., greater intraspecific variation) have wider trophic niches? Issues similar to the latter have been discussed by Dennison & Baker (1991) and Griffen & Mosblack (2011), who studied the morphology of birds and crabs, respectively, and Bolnick et al (2007), who analyzed temperate fish and noted that generalized populations exhibit more niche variation.…”