Comparative Effectiveness of Multiple Exercise Interventions in the Treatment of Mental Health Disorders: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis

Abstract

Background The efficacy of exercise interventions in the treatment of mental health disorders is well known, but research is lacking on the most efficient exercise type for specific mental health disorders. Objective The present study aimed to compare and rank the effectiveness of various exercise types in the treatment of mental health disorders. Methods The PubMed, Web of Science, PsycINFO, SPORTDiscus, CINAHL databases, and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials as well as Google Scholar were searched up to December 2021. We performed pairwise and network meta-analyses as well as meta-regression analyses for mental health disorders in general and each type of mental health disorder, with alterations in symptom severity as the primary outcome. Results A total of 6456 participants from 117 randomized controlled trials were surveyed. The multimodal exercise (71%) had the highest probability of being the most efficient exercise for relieving depressive symptoms. While resistance exercise (60%) was more likely to be the most effective treatment for anxiety disorder, patients with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) benefited more from mind–body exercise (52%). Furthermore, resistance exercise (31%) and multimodal exercise (37%) had more beneficial effects in the treatment of the positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenia, respectively. The length of intervention and exercise frequency independently moderated the effects of mind–body exercise on depressive (coefficient = 0.14, p = .03) and negative schizophrenia (coefficient = 0.96, p = .04) symptoms. Conclusion Multimodal exercise ranked best for treating depressive and negative schizophrenic symptoms, while resistance exercise seemed to be more beneficial for those with anxiety-related and positive schizophrenic symptoms. Mind–body exercise was recommended as the most promising exercise type in the treatment of PTSD. However, the findings should be treated with caution due to potential risk of bias in at least one dimension of assessment and low-to-moderate certainty of evidence. Trial Registration This systematic review was registered in the PROSPERO international prospective register of systematic reviews (CRD42022310237).

Exercise sustains motor function in Parkinson's disease: Evidence from 109 randomized controlled trials on over 4,600 patients

“…Second, the significant change in motor function may be attributed to extra motor learning. Multiple skill acquisitions being involved in intervention could promote the positive transfer of training, that is, a skill acquired in one circumstance enhances skill acquisition and problem-solving ability development in another circumstance (Krasnow and Wilmerding, 2016 ; Zou et al, 2021 ; Yu et al, 2022 ). This explanation is further supported by our findings that both the second and third likely best exercise forms (i.e., yoga and multimodal training) to general motor function are characterized by multiple movement tasks (Yeung et al, 2018 ; Yu et al, 2021 ).…”

Adaptogens on Depression-Related Outcomes: A Systematic Integrative Review and Rationale of Synergism with Physical Activity

“…Future studies integrating adaptogen consumption and a physical exercise program are expected. Regular practice of physical activity has demonstrated a high impact on both physical and mental health in humans [ 119 , 120 ]. These effects point to physical exercise as a protective and inducing agent of biochemical agents responsible for aspects such as the speed of information processing, memory, attention, neuronal signaling, and coordination [ 121 ].…”

Sport and exercise as medicine in the prevention and treatment of depression

“…The finding that exercise alleviates symptoms of depression to a similar extent as pharmacotherapy supports the adoption of exercise as an alternative treatment approach for the management of non-severe depression in adults. Furthermore, a network meta-analysis was conducted to compare the effectiveness of distinct exercise types, such as aerobic exercise, resistance exercise, mind-body exercise (such as yoga, Tai Chi and dance), stretching and multimodal exercise, which combines at least two types of exercise, on mental health disorders including depression ( 23 ). Aerobic exercise, mind-body exercise and multimodal exercise were shown to have significant effects, with moderate-to-large effect sizes, on depressive symptoms when compared with control conditions ( 23 ).…”

“…Furthermore, a network meta-analysis was conducted to compare the effectiveness of distinct exercise types, such as aerobic exercise, resistance exercise, mind-body exercise (such as yoga, Tai Chi and dance), stretching and multimodal exercise, which combines at least two types of exercise, on mental health disorders including depression ( 23 ). Aerobic exercise, mind-body exercise and multimodal exercise were shown to have significant effects, with moderate-to-large effect sizes, on depressive symptoms when compared with control conditions ( 23 ). These findings suggest that various distinct exercise modalities may have clinically meaningful benefits in the treatment of depression and should therefore be considered as complement to medication.…”

“…This suggests that combining various exercise types is likely to contribute to greater improvements in depression. In addition, the result of meta-regression indicated that intervention length (4–12 weeks), rather than exercise frequency and session duration, moderated the positive effects of mind-body exercise ( 23 ). This confirmed findings of previous meta-analyses, which had shown that exercise length was the only characteristic related to the effect size for depression treatment ( 24 , 25 ), with intervention periods of 9–12 weeks being associated with the largest reduction.…”