Comparative analyses of competitive advantage using Porter diamond model (the case of MSMEs in Himachal Pradesh)

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to measure and analyze the competitive advantage of micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) based upon the Porter’s diamond framework. The major objective is to contribute toward better understanding of various determinants of the diamond model in context within Indian MSMEs. Design/methodology/approach Extent review of the literature has been done to identify various critical factors contributing to developing a competitive advantage. Exploratory factor analysis and internal consistency tests were performed to verify scales validity and reliability of measuring instrument (questionnaire). In research design, a case study approach has been used, in which MSMEs operating in the pharmaceutical, electrical and electronics, automobile, food and textile sectors were considered. Findings Study findings indicate that the pharmaceutical sector is more competitive followed by food (112.491) as revealed by the high value of surface area i.e. 150.931. The competitiveness among MSME sectors is mostly affected by demand conditions followed by firm strategy, structure and rivalry. Moreover, the score of diamond axes indicates significant difference with respect to determinants. For instance, in the textile sector, the determinants such as factor conditions and related and supporting industries scored low, for example, 4.710 and 4.280, respectively, which indicates it needs to be strengthened as this sector stands at last position with minimum surface area, for example, 67.398. Research limitations/implications Owing to the time and resource constraints, this study was conducted in MSMEs situated in the state of Himachal Pradesh, India, and thus generalizations of results are rather limited. Practical implications This study is one of the original being undertaken by authors which helps to underline the importance of various determinants which may help the MSME units to improve competitiveness by implementing effective competitive strategies. The study could be extended to other regions of the country. Originality/value This study is a result of extended research on competitiveness and provides an instrument to measure firm ability to be competitive. CEO’s, managers and policy makers from industries as well as government will be able to use this to evaluate their competitive positioning and identify key problem areas which required improvements.

Porter’s Diamond Approaches and the Competitiveness Web

“…The author concludes that this study challenges a -common approach that attributes Turkish contractors" success in international markets to labour cost advantages and geographic and cultural proximity to several promising markets.‖ Specifically, by applying the diamond framework, it seems that -Turkish contractors" advantages are found not to be limited to "factor conditions" and "chance" events. Overall, beyond the above application cases (Byun & Mann, 2011;Dögl, Holtbrügge, & Schuster, 2012;Harzing & Giroud, 2014;Kharub & Sharma, 2017), it is clear that the use of -diamond's‖ analytical methodology to date is both broad and multifaceted (Afzal, Lawrey, & Gope, 2019;Fang, Zhou, Wang, Ye, & Guo, 2018;Wonglimpiyarat, 2017). Nevertheless, various criticisms and extensions are also present.…”

Diagnostics of the Challenges and Potential Solutions to Improve Export Competitiveness in International Markets: The Case of Pakistani Readymade Garments Industry

“…If the domestic demand is high, firms will increase investment and achieve economies of scale which will help to gain competitive advantages. In the countries where local buyers have sophisticated demands, the firms are required to upgrade and achieve high standards to respond to the strong challenges (Kharub & Sharma, 2017). In demand conditions, another highlighted challenge was the lack of own brands in the global markets.…”

“…A similar research study in India also found low results using Porter's Diamond Model in an examination of the textile sector. Despite tremendous potential in exports, the Indian textile industry is unable to fully exploit its potential due to government policies, a lack of entrepreneurship skills and limited financial resources (Kharub & Sharma, 2017). Another key challenge highlighted was the law and order situation in Pakistan, which received an 88 percent score.…”

Branding: A competitive strategy in the wine industry

“…El concepto de competitividad en estos días ha sido una de las palabras más utilizadas en el campo económico y se ha convertido en un concepto ambiguo debido al múltiple análisis que se ha tenido durante estos años [39,40]. Según Nedić, Lepojević, Despotović & Cvetanović, [41] la competitividad se refiere a la capacidad de individuos, empresas, comunidades, países y regiones para competir y ser mejores, más innovadores y más creativos que otros interesados en elámbito local, nacional, regional y global; en la creación de valor agregado, y esto comenzó porque según Kharub [48] "las estrategias industriales tradicionales son cada vez menos efectivas" y la competitividad ha contribuido a cambiar el entorno empresarial para mejorar en todo el mundo.…”