4,5 several (lactose, fructose, sorbitol and wheat) are now incorporated into a popular dietary approach: the low-FODMAP (fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides and polyols) diet. [4][5][6] These molecules, poorly absorbed in the small intestine, are thought to generate increased, osmotically driven intraluminal volumes 7 and to be fermented by the colonic microbiota to short chain fatty acids and gases; thereby generating pain, bloating and distension in a viscerally sensitive subject. 8 Clinical trials supported this hypothesis (reviewed in reference 9); soon the low-FOD-MAP diet became a cornerstone of IBS management.The systematic review and meta-analysis by Rindom Krogsgaard and colleagues casts a cold eye on clinical trials of the low-FODMAP diet and points up a number of shortcomings: unrepresentative study population (tertiary referral rather than primary care), lack of blinding, inappropriate controls (in terms of diet or other intervention) and, most tellingly, short duration of exposure (maximum 6 weeks in a disorder that lasts a lifetime). 9 Furthermore, the reintroduction phase, fundamental to the low-FODMAP strategy, has not been subjected to critical assessment. Their analysis, indeed, leads them to conclude that much of the impact of a low-FODMAP diet may be a placebo effect.