Cognitive Styles, Gender, and Student Academic Performance in Engineering Education

Abstract

Cognitive styles affect the learning process positively if tasks are matched to the cognitive style of learners. This effect becomes more pronounced in complex education, such as in engineering. We attempted to critically assess the effect of cognitive styles and gender on students’ academic performance in eight engineering majors to understand whether a cognitive style preference is associated with certain majors. We used the Cognitive Style Indicator (CoSI) with a sample of n = 584 engineering students. Multiple standard statistical tests, regression tree analysis, and cluster analysis showed that none of the three cognitive styles was exclusively associated with better performance. However, students who had a stronger preference for a cognitive style were more likely to perform better. Gender, the major, and students’ clarity about their cognitive style were shown to be the best predictors of academic performance. Female students performed better and were clearer about their preferred cognitive style, whereas male students were more capable of adapting to different learning tasks. Furthermore, certain engineering majors were shown to be associated with certain cognitive styles. We concluded the study with theoretical and practical implications for engineering education and suggestions for further research.

Applying active learning method to improve teaching outcomes in architectural engineering courses

“…Building on the literature review that illustrated various active learning practices and their effect on the quality of learning and satisfaction of the students, this study used mixed qualitative and quantitative methods to achieve the goal through a case study and survey (Creswell, 2014). Several proceeding studies used similar empirical methods (Al Maani, 2022;Alalouch, 2021;Mushtaha et al, 2022). Alalouch's study (2021), for instance, used a selfreporting survey of a 5-point agreement scale based on Cools and Broeck (2007) to investigate cognitive styles, gender and student academic performance in engineering education in the College of Engineering, Sultan Qaboos University.…”

“…Building on the literature review that illustrated various active learning practices and their effect on the quality of learning and satisfaction of the students, this study used mixed qualitative and quantitative methods to achieve the goal through a case study and survey (Creswell, 2014). Several proceeding studies used similar empirical methods (Al Maani, 2022; Alalouch, 2021; Mushtaha et al. , 2022).…”

EFL learners' learning styles and their reading performance

“…Learners need to recognize the learning strategies and their strengths and, therefore, develop their learning capacity,also, they can take advantage of learning styles by coordinating learning strategies with them. When teaching tasks are aligned with learners' cognitive styles, their learning capabilities will be enhanced [2]. This is a form of engineering education.…”

Revisiting learning styles and autonomy in the design studio: an undergraduate assessment

“…This is not to be confused with cognitive styles, which refer to individual processing differences that are inextricably linked to a person's cognitive system (Peterson et al, 2009). Cognitive styles, in contrast to learning styles, are relatively fixed, stable and may even be innate preferences (Alalouch, 2021;Peterson et al, 2009).…”

“…, 2009). Cognitive styles, in contrast to learning styles, are relatively fixed, stable and may even be innate preferences (Alalouch, 2021; Peterson et al. , 2009).…”