Cognitive anatomy of tutor learning: Lessons learned with SimStudent.

Abstract

This article describes an advanced learning technology used to investigate hypotheses about learning by teaching. The proposed technology is an instance of a teachable agent, called SimStudent, that learns skills (e.g., for solving linear equations) from examples and from feedback on performance. SimStudent has been integrated into an online, gamelike environment in which students act as “tutors” and can interactively teach SimStudent by providing it with examples and feedback. We conducted 3 classroom “in vivo” studies to better understand how and when students learn (or fail to learn) by teaching. One of the strengths of interactive technologies is their ability to collect detailed process data on the nature and timing of student activities. The primary purpose of this article is to provide an in-depth analysis across 3 studies to understand the underlying cognitive and social factors that contribute to tutor learning by making connections between outcome and process data. The results show several key cognitive and social factors that are correlated with tutor learning. The accuracy of students’ responses (i.e., feedback and hints), the quality of students’ explanations during tutoring, and the appropriateness of tutoring strategy (i.e., problem selection) all positively affected SimStudent’s learning, which further positively affected students’ learning. The results suggest that implementing adaptive help for students on how to tutor and solve problems is a crucial component for successful learning by teaching.

Modelling Human Teaching Tactics and Strategies for Tutoring Systems: 14 Years On

“…A variation on reflective theories of learning has been the emergence of systems aimed to help learners learn by getting them to teach the material to be learned to someone else, typically a simulated fellow student such as Betty's Brain (Leelawong and Biswas 2008). The issue of how much this helps a learner to learn has been explored in a series of studies using SimStudent (Matsuda et al 2013). SimStudent is a simulated student that uses machine-learning techniques to build production rules expressing a skill such as solving a simple equation in algebra.…”

Building the Learning Path of Mathematical Creative Thinking of Students on Geometry Topics by Implementing Metacognitive Approach

“…Experiment in 2 different places. This study reveals that prior knowledge greatly influenced the learning process [6]. In addition, regression analysis shows that prior knowledge is the dominant facemask affecting post-test results for procedural ability testing.…”

A Tale of Three Cases: Examining Accuracy, Efficiency, and Process Differences in Diagnosing Virtual Patient Cases

“…Investigations of CBLEs have demonstrated that learning can be supported in a wide range of educational domains, from algebra to history (e.g., Anderson, Corbett, Koedinger, & Pelletier, 1995;Beal, Walles, Arroyo, & Woolf, 2007;Matsuda et al, 2013;Poitras, Lajoie, & Hong, 2011;Vanlehn et al, 2005). This body of work elucidates the salient role that technology plays in learning experiences and outcomes.…”