China’s engagement with Kazakhstan and Russia’s Zugzwang: Why is Nur-Sultan incurring regional power hedging?

Abstract

Grappling with the contemporary topos of a Sino-Russian Entente, Kazakhstan is caught between a delicate long-term peer-competition and potentially a structural rivalry involving the two Eurasian Leviathans, China and Russia. Acknowledging this perspective, Nur-Sultan is inducing hedging dynamics, fishing for a better range of net benefits, while playing a significant fulcrum role central to the regional geopolitical and geo-economic matrix. Although Russia is retaining the prevailing role in the security domain, China is catching up with Russia in various economic indices, notably generated by the Belt and Road Initiative. Utilizing the conceptualization of hierarchy in international relations adapted from the work of David A. Lake, this paper outlines how Nur-Sultan’s interests and preferences are acknowledged by the respective dominants, as a basis for social contracting processes to generate a dual hierarchical order in Central Asia.

Kazakhstan's media coverage of China: How the Belt and Road Initiative strengthens geopolitical ties

“…Drawing on neo-Gramscianism and neoliberal institutionalism, the authors suggested a notable shift in regional hegemony, proposing that China, bolstered by the strengthening of the BRI, could emerge as a hegemon shaping the 'forms of state' in Kazakhstan. Ohle, Cook, and Han's (2020) research delved into the complex geopolitical dynamics involving Kazakhstan, Russia, and China, centering on the BRI and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO). Kazakhstan's nuanced diplomatic approach, aligning with Russia while strategically recognizing China for additional benefits, underscored its diplomatic agility.…”

Trade-offs and inconsistencies of the Russian foreign policy: The case of Eurasia

“…Preserving its alignments with Moscow, Kazakhstan considers rapprochement with China as valuable option in the overall framework of its developmental strategy that presupposes keeping and even expanding various forms of bilateral and multilateral cooperation. The hedging strategy has allowed Kazakhstan not to become client state of any of the two hegemons promoting its own political and economic interests, and clearly asserting and protecting its sovereignty (Ohle et al, 2020 Vanderhill et al (2020).…”