Changes in soil organic matter over 70 years in continuous arable and ley–arable rotations on a sandy loam soil in England

Abstract

The sequestration in soil of organic carbon (SOC) derived from atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) by replacing arable crops with leys, has been measured over 70 years on a sandy loam soil. The experiment was designed initially to test the effect of leys on the yields of arable crops. A 3‐year grazed grass with clover (grass + clover) ley in a 5‐year rotation with arable crops increased percentage organic carbon (%OC) in the top 25 cm of the soil from 0.98 to 1.23 in 28 years, but with little further increase during the next 40 years with all‐grass leys given fertilizer nitrogen (N). In this second period, OC inputs were balanced by losses, suggesting that about 1.3% OC might be near the equilibrium content for this rotation. Including 3‐year lucerne (Medicago sativa) leys had little effect on %OC over 28 years, but after changing to grass + clover leys, %OC increased to 1.24 during the next 40 years. Eight‐year leys (all grass with N or grass + clover) in 10‐year rotations with arable crops were started in the 1970s, and after three rotations %OC had increased to ca. 1.40 in 2000–2009. Over 70 years, %OC declined from 0.98 to 0.94 in an all‐arable rotation with mainly cereals and to 0.82 with more root crops. Applications of 38 t ha−1 farmyard manure (FYM) every fifth year increased %OC by 0.13% by the mid‐1960s when applications ceased. Soil treated with FYM still contained 0.10% more OC in 2000–2009. Changes in the amount of OC have been modelled with RothC‐26.3 and estimated inputs of C for selected rotations. Little of the OC input during the 70 years has been retained; most was retained in the grazed ley rotation, but 9 t ha−1 only of a total input of 189 t ha−1. In other rotations more than 98% of the total OC input was lost. Despite large losses of C, annual increases in OC of 4‰ are possible on this soil type with the inclusion of grass or grass + clover leys or the application of FYM, but only for a limited period. Such increases in SOC might help to limit increases in atmospheric CO2.Highlights Can leys sequester significant amounts of atmospheric CO 2 in SOM and contribute to the 4‰ initiative?Changes in the percentage and amount of OC were measured and modelled over 70 years and OC losses estimated.Three‐year grass or grass + clover leys increased %OC, but only to an equilibrium level that was then maintained.Despite large losses, sequestering CO 2‐C at 4‰ year−1 by growing grass or grass + clover leys is possible.

Major limitations to achieving “4 per 1000” increases in soil organic carbon stock in temperate regions: Evidence from long‐term experiments at Rothamsted Research, United Kingdom

“…Changes in SOC in the different rotations are described by Johnston et al. () and summarized here in a later section.…”

“…Johnston et al. () considered that these differences were due to the additional number of soil cultivations needed to grow root crops. Changes in SOC in the different rotations are described by Johnston et al.…”

“… Adapted from Tables , and S2, Johnston et al., . Although there was not a significant effect of FYM for individual rotations, when all rotations were considered together, there was a significant effect. …”

“…The Woburn Ley‐arable experiment (Johnston et al., ), started in 1938, compares the effects of 3‐year arable cropping and 3‐year or 8‐year leys on the yields of two subsequent arable crops. Soils on which 3‐year lucerne leys were grown until 1970 showed only a very modest increase in SOC in the 0–23 cm soil layer over 30 years.…”

“…Soils on which 3‐year lucerne leys were grown until 1970 showed only a very modest increase in SOC in the 0–23 cm soil layer over 30 years. This has been attributed to the wide‐spaced rows of lucerne with its main tap root rather than a dense mass of shallower roots, typical of grasslands (Johnston et al., ). When the lucerne ley was replaced by a grass/clover mixture, SOC increased by at least 4‰ per year over the next 35 years (Table ).…”