Changes in Cognitive Outcomes in Early Childhood: The Role of Family Income and Volatility

Abstract

Associations between family income and child developmental outcomes are well documented. However, family income is not static but changes over time. Although this volatility represents income shocks that are likely to affect children’s lives, very few studies have so far examined its effect on early cognitive development. This study investigated associations between family income, volatility, and changes in cognitive outcomes in early childhood and examined whether these associations are dependent on a family’s overall income position. Data for the study spanned five waves of the Growing Up in Scotland longitudinal survey (N = 3,621). Findings indicate that income volatility was more prevalent among disadvantaged sociodemographic groups. In addition to average income, short-term volatility was associated with changes in child cognitive outcomes from ages 3 to 5. While upward volatility was associated with gains in expressive vocabulary, downward and fluctuating volatility were associated with declines in child problem-solving abilities. The association between volatility and changes in cognitive outcomes was similar for both children living in poverty and those from medium–high-income households. Our results suggest that policies aiming to cushion all families from negative income shocks, boost family income to ensure stability, and take low-income families out of poverty will have a significant impact on children’s cognitive development. Additionally, a more nuanced conceptualization of income is needed to understand its multidimensional impact on developmental outcomes.

Differential longitudinal effects of frequent sweetened food consumption at different exposure ages on child cognitive, language, and motor development

“…Highly educated mothers tended to purchase more books and had higher academic expectations for their children [ 26 , 27 ]. Household income positively affected cognitive development, whereas low family income and poverty negatively impacted cognitive development [ 28 , 29 ].…”

Annual Research Review: The power of predictability – patterns of signals in early life shape neurodevelopment and mental health trajectories

“…Far fewer studies have considered unpredictability in income. Income unpredictability both in terms of fluctuations in income over months and income shocks (substantial income increases or decreases) are linked to detrimental impacts on preschooler's cognitive performance (Sosu & Schmidt, 2022) as well as adolescent school engagement (Gennetian, Wolf, Hill, & Morris, 2015). These studies indicate that unpredictable changes in income are associated with cognitive and school performance from early childhood through adolescence beyond associations with income level.…”

Childhood unpredictability research within the developmental psychopathology framework: Advances, implications, and future directions

“…Unpredictability in housing, finances, parental employment, and parental mental health is linked to alterations in cognitivebehavioral processes and outcomes, including effortful control, impulsivity, school outcomes, substance use, behavior problems, and neurodevelopment related to cognitive processes (Davis & Glynn, 2024;DeCandia et al, 2022;Doom et al, 2016;Fowler et al, 2015;Schneider & Harknett, 2022;Sosu & Schmidt, 2022). Similarly, household chaos is linked to poorer self-regulation, greater externalizing problems, substance use, and other cognitive outcomes (Andrews et al, 2021;Davis & Glynn, 2024;Deater-Deckard et al, 2009;Delker et al, 2020;Dumas et al, 2005).…”