Challenges of research recruitment in a university setting in England

Abstract

The recruitment is an integral part of most research projects in medical sciences involving human participants. In health promotion research, there is increasing work on the impact of environments. Settings represent environments such as schools where social, physical and psychological development unfolds. In this study, we investigated weight gain in students within a university setting. Barriers to access and recruitment of university students within a specific setting, in the context of health research are discussed. An online survey on health behaviours of first year students across 101 universities in England was developed. Ethics committees of each institutions were contacted to obtain permission to recruit and access their students. Recruitment adverts were standardized and distributed within restrictions imposed by universities. Three time points and incentives were used. Several challenges in recruiting from a university setting were found. These included (i) ethics approval, (ii) recruitment approval, (iii) navigating restrictions on advertisement and (iv) logistics of varying university academic calendars. We also faced challenges of online surveys including low recruitment, retention and low eligibility of respondents. From the 101 universities, 28 allowed dissemination of adverts. We obtained 1026 responses at T1, 599 at T2 and 497 at T3. The complete-case sample represented 13% of those originally recruited at T1. Conducting research on students within the university setting is a time consuming and challenging task. To improve research-based health promotion, universities could work together to increase consistency as to their policies on student recruitment.

Determinants of eating behaviours in Australian university students: A cross‐sectional analysis

“…However, the use of tools/methods with good validity reduces the potential bias from self‐reporting. The study sample was a small proportion of the total student body (9.1%), however, this is similar to other online surveys in university students using convenience sampling …”

Evaluation of a tertiary sustainability experiential learning program

“…Chief among these is that participation in the evaluation was voluntary and this affected recruitment (only 34% of all eligible students participated in the baseline survey and only four students attended the interview) and resulted in some attrition (59% of participants dropped out between baseline and evaluation). These are known challenges in research on tertiary students (Vadeboncoeur et al , 2017) and while they do impact the results, the current study is nevertheless useful for its exploratory value. To create more certainty in results, evaluations of SLED and other, similar programs could use interviews conducted in-class time, research designs that use incentives, opt-out methods or even participation for course credit, thus recruiting a larger sample for greater statistical power (Padilla–Walker et al , 2005).…”

Primary and secondary data in emergency medicine health services research – a comparative analysis in a regional research network on multimorbid patients

“…Whether this feasibility of comparisons as well as the seemingly negligible impact of time restrictions to recruitment can be generalized to other clinical settings is beyond the scope of this article. As available literature suggests, recruiting and data collection heavily depend on the properties of certain settings [ 41 – 43 ].…”