To develop solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) capable of operating on sulfur‐containing practical fuels at intermediate temperatures, further improvement of the sulfur tolerance of a Ni + BaZr0.4Ce0.4Y0.2O3‐δ (BZCY) anode is attempted through the addition of some metal modifiers (Fe, Co, and Ag) by a one‐pot synthesis approach. The effects of these modifiers on the electrical conductivity, morphology, sulfur tolerance, and electrochemical activity of the anode are systematically studied. As a result, the cell with Ag‐modified Ni + BZCY anode demonstrates highest power output when operated on 1000 ppm H2S‐H2 fuel. Furthermore, the Ag‐modified anode displays much better stability than Ni + BZCY with 1000 ppm H2S‐H2 fuel at 600°C. These results suggest that the addition of Ag modifier into Ni + BZCY is a promising and efficient method for improving the sulfur tolerance of SOFCs. © 2017 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 63: 4287–4295, 2017