A small pool of NK1.1+ CD8+ T cells is harbored among the “conventional” CD8+ T cell compartment. Conclusions driven from analysis of immune responses mediated by cytotoxic CD8+ T cells are often made on the total population, which includes these “contaminating” NK1.1+ CD8+ T cells. An as yet unresolved question is whether NK1.1+ CD8+ cells are conventional T cells that acquire NK1.1 expression upon activation or delineation into memory phenotype, or whether they are a distinct cell population that induces immune responses in a different manner than conventional T cells. To address this question, we used the Listeria monocytogenes model of infection and followed CD8+ NK1.1+ T cells alongside NK1.1− CD8+ T cells in each phase of the immune response: innate, effector and memory. Our central finding is that CD8+ NK1.1+ cells and conventional NK1.1− CD8+ T cells both contribute to the adaptive immune response to Listeria, but only CD8+ NK1.1+ cells were equipped with the ability to provide a rapid innate immune response, as demonstrated by early and antigen-independent IFNγ production, granzyme B expression, and degranulation. More importantly, purified conventional CD8+ T cells alone in the absence of any “contaminating” CD8+ NK1.1+ cells were not sufficient to provide early protection to lethally infected mice. These results highlight the role of CD8+ NK1.1+ T cells in mounting early innate responses important for host defense and support the therapeutic potential of this subset to improve the effectiveness of protective immunity.