We analyze the Casimir force between two parallel infinite metal cylinders, with nearby metal plates (sidewalls), using complementary methods for mutual confirmation. The attractive force between cylinders is shown to have a nonmonotonic dependence on the separation to the plates. This intrinsically multi-body phenomenon, which occurs with either one or two sidewalls (generalizing an earlier result for squares between two sidewalls), does not follow from any simple two-body force description. We can, however, explain the nonmonotonicity by considering the screening (enhancement) of the interactions by the fluctuating charges (currents) on the two cylinders, and their images on the nearby plate(s). Furthermore, we show that this effect also implies a nonmonotonic dependence of the cylinder-plate force on the cylinder-cylinder separation.PACS numbers: 12.20. Ds, 42.50.Ct, 42.50.Lc Casimir forces arise from quantum vacuum fluctuations, and have been the subject of considerable theoretical and experimental interest [1,2,3,4]. We consider here the force between metallic cylinders with one or two parallel metal sidewalls ( Fig. 1) using two independent exact computational methods, and find an unusual nonmonotonic dependence of the force on the sidewall separation. These nonmonotonic effects cannot be predicted by commonly used two-body Casimir-force estimates, such as the proximity-force approximation (PFA) [5,6] that is based on the parallel-plate limit, or by addition of Casimir-Polder 'atomic' interactions (CPI) [6,7,8].In previous work, we demonstrated a similar nonmonotonic force between two metal squares in proximity to two parallel metal sidewalls, for either perfect or realistic metals [9]. This work, with perfect-metal cylinders [10], demonstrates that the effect is not limited to squares (i.e., it does not arise from sharp corners or parallel flat surfaces), nor does it require two sidewalls. The nonmonotonicity stems from a competition between forces from transverse electric (TE) and transverse magnetic (TM) field polarizations: In the latter case, the interaction between fluctuating charges on the cylinders is screened by opposing image charges, in the former case it is enhanced by analogous fluctuating image currents. Furthermore, we show that a related nonmonotonic variation arises for the force between the cylinders and a sidewall as a function of separation between the cylinders, a geometry potentially amenable to experiment.Casimir forces are not two-body interactions: quantum fluctuations in one object induce fluctuations throughout the system which in turn act back on the first object. However, both the PFA and CPI view Casimir forces as the result of attractive two-body ("pairwise") interactions. They are reasonable approximations only in certain limits (e.g., low curvature for PFA), and can fail qualitatively as well as quantitatively otherwise. Pairwise estimates fail to account for two important aspects of the Casimir forces in the geometry we consider [11]. First, a monotonic pairwise attrac...