Carbohydrate structure: the rocky road to automation

Abstract

With the introduction of intuitive graphical software, structural biologists who are not experts in crystallography are now able to build complete protein or nucleic acid models rapidly. In contrast, carbohydrates are in a wholly different situation: scant automation exists, with manual building attempts being sometimes toppled by incorrect dictionaries or refinement problems. Sugars are the most stereochemically complex family of biomolecules and, as pyranose rings, have clear conformational preferences. Despite this, all refinement programs may produce high-energy conformations at medium to low resolution, without any support from the electron density. This problem renders the affected structures unusable in glyco-chemical terms. Bringing structural glycobiology up to 'protein standards' will require a total overhaul of the methodology. Time is of the essence, as the community is steadily increasing the production rate of glycoproteins, and electron cryo-microscopy has just started to image them in precisely that resolution range where crystallographic methods falter most.

Structural analysis of glycoproteins: building N-linked glycans withCoot

“…The work described here is motivated to help to tackle the challenge of accurately interpreting both crystallographic and cryo-EM maps of glycans and in part to address the concerns raised by Agirre et al (2017). The LMA mode is the mode that we imagine that users will find most useful.…”

Structure of the chlorovirus PBCV-1 major capsid glycoprotein determined by combining crystallographic and carbohydrate molecular modeling approaches

“…To gain insight into the architecture of these glycans, we reexamined the previous X-ray diffraction data of the Vp54 crystals (13). In general, crystallographic analysis of carbohydrates is still a challenging task (14), and during the original study, the glycan structures were unknown; as a consequence, fitting potential glycans into the electron density data was performed using sugars now known to be incorrect. Glucosamine (not Glc) was placed near the sites of glycosylation, and Man was used to fill out the interpretable electron densities.…”

Making glycoproteins a little bit sweeter withPDB-REDO

“…In the context of PDB-REDO, however, this process should be achieved in a fully automated and unsupervised manner. This level of automation is not yet available, although steady progress in this direction is being made (Agirre et al, 2017). Overall, glycoprotein structure is not yet optimal, but the improvements discussed here together with the many other developments in the field are moving structural quality in the right direction.…”